The escalating tensions in Durban, particularly around the planned anti-migrant protests set for June 30, have led to a series of alarming incidents involving migrants, many of whom are fleeing with nothing but their lives. On Tuesday, around 5am, a group of approximately 100 individuals attacked a group of Mozambican migrants in Clermont, KwaZulu-Natal. According to Narciso Devesse, a Mozambican national, the attackers used machetes and robbed them of their belongings. The victims included a nine-month pregnant woman and a three-year-old child. They were forced to flee with only their lives, having lost their clothing and money. Devesse recounted the harrowing experience outside a drive-in center, where he and others sought refuge. The attackers reportedly dumped the group at the site, leaving them stranded without support or shelter. Despite the chaos, two individuals managed to call the police, who later dropped the migrants off at the location. Good Samaritans donated food, yet access to the site remained restricted, highlighting the ongoing struggles faced by these displaced individuals.
The situation has intensified over the past five weeks, with asylum seekers and migrants camping outside the Che Guevara Home Affairs office. Among them are numerous families, including pregnant women and children. Deborah Ewing from the South African Palestine Movement, along with a group of monitors from various civil society and religious organizations, observed the scene. She noted that the refugees, primarily from the Democratic Republic of the Congo and other countries, are legally recognized but remain homeless, unable to secure shelter for over six weeks. Ewing expressed concerns about the safety of these individuals, emphasizing the need for collective efforts to ensure their well-being. Her presence underscores the role of civil society in monitoring and advocating for the rights of migrants during this volatile period.
Amnesty International has raised alarms regarding the rising xenophobia and the potential for violence amidst the anti-migrant protests. The organization has criticized the lack of political leadership to address the root causes of xenophobia and the growing climate of intimidation against foreign nationals. It highlighted the mobilization of a private anti-migrant group, March and March, which has set an unlawful June 30 deadline for undocumented migrants to leave the country. The group has also organized planned marches in various provinces. Amnesty warned that South Africa risks repeating its darkest historical moments if decisive action is not taken. Executive Director Shenilla Mohamed emphasized that while peaceful protest is supported, violence, intimidation, and unauthorized enforcement of immigration laws are unlawful and pose a grave danger. The organization pointed to the dangers of allowing vigilante groups to operate unchecked, as this contributes to a culture of impunity and escalates tensions.
The March and March Movement, represented by its leader Jacinta Ngobese-Zuma, has accused the South African government of failing to manage the issue of illegal immigration effectively. She criticized the president for not understanding the crisis, citing the low operational capacity of the border at 25%, leaving 75% unsecured. However, Amnesty clarified that legal frameworks in South Africa restrict such powers to specific serious offenses, with immigration enforcement being the domain of authorized state officials. The organization reiterated that anyone taking the law into their own hands is breaking the law and that the state must take responsibility for enforcing laws and ensuring the safety of all citizens.
Meanwhile, the impact of xenophobic violence has been felt across various regions, with reports of businesses being destroyed and homes violated. In Johannesburg, the aftermath of the nationwide xenophobic protests has left many South Africans and migrants grappling with the consequences of violence. Residents in Greenfields, Katlehong, and other areas have experienced the loss of property, personal injury, and even fatalities. One tragic incident involved the killing of 21-year-old Siphesihle Mncemeleni, a Somali national, who was shot after attempting to return a phone to his friend. His sister, Nompumelelo, recounted the emotional toll of losing her brother, highlighting the devastating impact of xenophobic violence on families.
The broader implications of these events extend beyond immediate harm, reflecting deeper societal issues. Reports indicate that the perception of migrants as contributors to economic problems is largely unfounded. Data shows that migrants, both documented and undocumented, play a crucial role in the economy, generating more value than they consume. The OECD-ILO study highlights that immigrants contribute significantly to national GDP, indicating their positive impact on productivity and job creation. Despite this, the narrative persists that migrants drain public resources and commit crimes, perpetuating harmful stereotypes.
The political landscape is equally complex, with calls for calm and resistance against xenophobia emerging from various sectors. Civil society organizations, academic institutions, and religious leaders are uniting to challenge the prevailing anti-migrant sentiments. The coalition representing 160 organizations, including civil society groups and trade unions, has called for the government to recognize the growing humanitarian crisis and redirect public anger toward systemic issues such as unemployment and service delivery failures. Leaders from the South African Council of Churches have also spoken out, urging the government to prioritize the safety and dignity of all individuals, regardless of their legal status.
As the situation continues to evolve, the focus remains on addressing the root causes of xenophobia and promoting inclusive policies that respect the rights of all citizens. The ongoing dialogue between activists, community leaders, and government representatives aims to foster a more equitable and just society, where the contributions of migrants are acknowledged and protected. The path forward requires sustained effort, collaboration, and a commitment to upholding the principles of human dignity and constitutional rights.
6 reports
IOL (Independent Online)Party-alignedLeftFactual 90Objective 804 days agoAmnesty International South Africa has expressed concerns about rising xenophobia and anti-migrant sentiment in the country, warning that unchecked hostility could lead to violence. The organization criticized private groups like 'March and March' for organizing anti-migrant protests and issuing an unlawful deadline for undocumented migrants to leave. These groups are placing blame on the government for failing to manage immigration issues effectively. Amnesty emphasized that individuals taking the law into their own hands violates legal frameworks and contributes to a climate of fear and discrimination. The organization also highlighted systemic failures in South Africa's asylum system, which leaves many migrants in legal limbo and exacerbates social tensions. Amnesty called for stronger government action to address these issues and protect the rights of all residents.
Bias read (Left): The article frames the issue through the lens of human rights and governmental accountability, emphasizing the dangers of xenophobia and the need for state intervention. It criticizes private groups for inciting violence and highlights systemic failures within the government, aligning more closely с
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 80): The article provides accurate information about Amnesty International's warnings regarding xenophobia and the activities of March and March. It presents both sides fairly, citing statements from Amnesty and March and March leader Jacinta Ngobese-Zuma, maintaining a balanced tone.
IOL (Independent Online)Party-alignedLeftFactual 90Objective 703 days ago ‘We fled with only our lives’: Migrants recount brutal attack as Durban tensions escalate ahead of protestsMozambican migrant Narciso Devesse recounted being attacked with a machete by a group of over 100 people in Clermont, KwaZulu-Natal, during early morning hours. The assault, which included theft of belongings and forced displacement, is linked to rising anti-immigrant tensions ahead of planned protests on June 30. Devesse and his companions, including a pregnant woman and her young child, were abandoned by authorities after seeking help from police. Asylum seekers, primarily from the Democratic Republic of the Congo, have been living in tents outside the Che Guevara Home Affairs office for over five weeks, facing harsh conditions and lacking proper shelter. Civil society groups, such as the South African Palestine Movement, are monitoring the situation and advocating for the safety of displaced individuals. Meanwhile, local organizations warn against vigilante actions and urge peaceful resolution.
Bias read (Left): The article frames the incident as part of a broader pattern of anti-immigrant sentiment and state failure to protect vulnerable populations. It highlights the systemic neglect of asylum seekers and emphasizes the role of civil society in advocating for their rights. While the article does not overt
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 70): Factuality is high with detailed accounts from a migrant survivor and specific allegations of attacks. Objectivity is moderate as the article presents personal testimonies but lacks broader contextual information or counterpoints.
Daily MaverickIndependentLeftFactual 85Objective 752 days agoThe article discusses ongoing xenophobic violence in Johannesburg, South Africa, following the June 30 protests. It highlights the impact on both local residents and migrant communities, including incidents of property destruction, personal assaults, and a fatal shooting in Alexandra. The article quotes victims' families and local authorities, noting that while the police claim stability, many communities experienced fear and unrest. Over 900 arrests were reported nationally, but only 82 occurred in Gauteng, indicating a disparity in law enforcement response across regions.
Bias read (Left): The article frames the xenophobic violence as a systemic issue affecting migrant communities, emphasizing the human toll and lack of effective policing. While it cites official statements, it focuses on the lived experiences of victims and criticizes the limited police action in Gauteng, suggesting左
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 75): Factual claims align with cross-source consensus on protests and government warnings. Objectivity is maintained through balanced reporting on both concerns about immigration and calls for non-violence.
Daily MaverickIndependentLeftFactual 80Objective 853 days ago THE MIGRANT MYTH: What South Africa’s anti-migration fury keeps getting wrongThe article challenges the common narrative in South Africa that undocumented migrants are a drain on the economy and public services. It highlights the case of Mpho, an undocumented migrant from Malawi who built a successful small business in Cape Town and contributes to the informal economy despite being officially unrecognized. The piece argues that the prevailing anti-migration sentiment is based on misinformation and fails to acknowledge the economic contributions of migrants. It references official data showing that the foreign-born population in South Africa grew slightly between 2011 and 2022, while their share of the population declined. The article cites a 2018 OECD-ILO study indicating that immigrants contributed more to national GDP than their proportion of employment suggested, and a World Bank analysis suggesting each immigrant worker generates approximately two jobs for citizens.
Bias read (Left): The article frames the anti-migration sentiment as misguided and rooted in misinformation, emphasizing the positive economic contributions of undocumented migrants. It critiques the dominant narrative and aligns with progressive perspectives that challenge xenophobic policies. While it presents data
Why these scores (Factual 80 · Objective 85): The article provides accurate information about the role of migrants in the economy and references official statistics. It presents a balanced view of the situation without taking sides, making it highly objective and factually sound.
Daily MaverickIndependentLeftyesterday Xenophobic unrest — you cannot condemn the fire after you lit the matchThis article discusses the rise of xenophobic violence in South Africa, particularly around 30 June, and examines the political and social factors contributing to it. It highlights how government officials and politicians, including ANC Secretary-General Fikile Mbalula, called for calm and condemned the violence, while also pointing out the irony that the same political establishment helped create the conditions for such unrest. The piece connects the current situation to historical events like the Stilfontein mine disaster, where 93 miners died due to systemic dehumanization and the government's failure to prioritize their safety. The article argues that the labeling of certain groups as 'illegal' or 'foreign' has led to a normalization of their mistreatment, making violent acts against them socially acceptable.
Bias read (Left): The article frames the xenophobic violence as a result of systemic political and institutional failures, emphasizing the role of government policies and rhetoric in dehumanizing marginalized communities. It criticizes the political establishment for creating an environment where xenophobia could fuf
Daily MaverickIndependentCenter4 days ago CALLS FOR CALM: Standing firm — the SA communities resisting xenophobia and protecting migrantsSouth African civil society organizations, religious leaders, and community activists are opposing rising xenophobic sentiments and calls for undocumented migrants to leave the country by 30 June. These groups argue that the growing hostility toward migrants is a humanitarian crisis and urge citizens to channel frustration over economic issues like unemployment and inequality toward the government rather than migrants. At an event held at Constitutional Hill, the coalition 'Siyafana Sonke' emphasized the need for peace and highlighted cases of migrants being harassed, losing homes, and even killed in the lead-up to the self-imposed deadline for migration. Activists accuse anti-immigrant groups such as 'March and March' of inciting violence through indirect messaging, warning that unrest could continue beyond formal protests. Reports indicate that some displaced migrants have faced extreme hardship, including giving birth on sidewalks due to lack of shelter.
Bias read (Center): The article presents perspectives from both anti-xenophobic advocates and critics of anti-immigrant groups without overtly favoring one side. It includes quotes from various stakeholders, including union representatives and think tanks, and does not exhibit strong biased language or one-sided source
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter
ZA
