ON
← Back to feed
New legal setback for Trump's conspiracy theories: The Supreme Court rejects a request to overturn 20,000 votes in California before the midterm elections
Spain🏛️ PoliticsProgressiveOverlooked by conservatives

New legal setback for Trump's conspiracy theories: The Supreme Court rejects a request to overturn 20,000 votes in California before the midterm elections

The US Supreme Court rejected a last-minute appeal by the Trump administration seeking to invalidate approximately 20,000 mail-in votes in California ahead of the mid-term legislative elections. Federal authorities argued these ballots should be discarded pending citizenship verification, while California officials maintained the data used to identify non-citizens was highly unreliable and likely included many legal citizens. This decision followed a series of recent judicial defeats for the administration, including a ruling by a DC district court judge who stated that the executive branch’s interference violated the constitutional clause reserving election rules to states and Congress. During related hearings, a Department of Justice attorney acknowledged to a federal judge that there was a high rate of error in the agency's voter identification data. The article notes that the administration has faced significant criticism for introducing these demands weeks before the election using a dataset that its own department admits is not entirely reliable.

The United States Supreme Court issued an emergency denial on Monday, refusing to halt the counting of approximately 20,000 mail-in ballots in California ahead of Tuesday’s midterm elections. The high court rejected a request from the Trump administration to force the state to set aside these specific ballots while officials verify the citizenship of the voters who cast them. The decision, delivered via a brief unsigned order without explanation, ends the federal government’s immediate legal challenge to the California election process. It stands as a final blow to the administration’s effort to intervene in the state’s vote tally less than 24 hours before polls close. The legal battle began in mid-October when the U.S. Department of Justice, led by Attorney General Todd Blanche, filed a lawsuit against California. The department alleged that it had identified more than 20,000 individuals registered to vote in the state who were likely not U.S. citizens. This identification process involved cross-referencing voter registration data with immigration databases maintained by the Department of Homeland Security. The administration argued that federal law prohibits non-citizens from voting and that counting these ballots would cause irreparable damage to the integrity of the election. They sought a limited injunction to keep the disputed ballots separate from valid ones until citizenship could be confirmed. California authorities strongly contested the reliability of the federal list. State officials stated that the data contained widespread errors and likely included many lawful U.S. citizens. They further explained that separating the ballots at this late stage was logistically impossible because the voting system decouples ballots from the envelopes containing voter information during processing. Attempting to isolate specific ballots now, they warned, would create delays and uncertainty in the count. An analysis submitted to the courts by researchers at the University of California found that 42 percent of the names on the government’s list did not even appear on the state’s voter rolls. Lower courts had already ruled against the federal government multiple times before the case reached the Supreme Court. On October 29, U.S. District Judge David O. Carter denied the initial request for a restraining order. Carter wrote that the method used by Washington to match data was plagued by uncertainties and errors. He warned that allowing the executive branch to discount votes based on unproven allegations would endanger democracy and violate constitutional principles that give states control over their own election procedures. Carter noted that granting such a last-minute petition would allow any party to generate chaos for political purposes, particularly given the proximity of the midterms. Following Carter’s ruling, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals heard an emergency appeal. Last Friday, a three-judge panel rejected the government’s request by a two-to-one margin. The majority opinion cited the Elections Clause of the Constitution, which assigns authority over election rules to states and Congress. The judges suggested that if the federal government believed different procedures were necessary for mail-in voting, it should propose changes to Congress rather than seeking intervention through the courts. Despite these setbacks, the administration escalated its efforts on Monday. Deputy Attorney General D. John Sauer filed the emergency motion with the Supreme Court, arguing that once California mixed the disputed ballots with valid ones, there would be no way to recover them. Sauer framed the request as a modest measure intended to buy time for verification rather than to invalidate any votes outright. However, the Supreme Court declined to intervene, leaving the lower court rulings intact. Other federal judges weighed in on similar issues this week. In Washington, D.C., Judge James Boasberg ordered the administration to cease making demands regarding California’s election process, stating that the executive branch had likely violated the Elections Clause by attempting to override state regulations. Meanwhile, in Los Angeles, District Judge Trina Thompson questioned the accuracy of the Department of Justice’s data during a hearing. She asked Kenneth Kao, a Justice Department lawyer, whether he agreed there was a high rate of error in the agency’s reports. Kao conceded that the statement was accurate, explaining that the department requested help from registrars to verify the validity of the voters. Bill Essayli, the federal prosecutor leading the Justice Department office in Los Angeles, defended the administration’s position in a press conference. He stated he was fully convinced that the individuals on the list lacked the right to vote, insisting that the claim was not speculation or theory. Conversely, California Governor Gavin Newsom accused Trump of preparing a strategy for months to declare the elections rigged. Rob Bonta, the California Attorney General, called the federal appeal another attempt to undermine elections and trample the rule of law, describing the move as desperate given polling data suggesting Democrats would win majorities in both chambers of Congress. The dispute highlights a broader conflict over election administration. While the administration has prioritized identifying non-citizen voters throughout the year, independent investigations and electoral authorities have consistently detected only minuscule rates of such fraud. A study by the Brennan Center for Justice indicated that instances of non-citizen voting are rare. The Supreme Court’s refusal to pause the count allows California’s election officials to proceed with processing the millions of mail-in ballots sent to the state’s roughly 23 million registered voters. Early voting has been underway since early October, with hundreds of thousands of ballots already counted. The outcome will determine control of the House of Representatives and the Senate.

How this report was made. Objective News wrote this report from 2 source articles, using AI-assisted synthesis under our methodology. It is our own text, not a copy of any single outlet. Read our methodology.

Responsible editor: Matej BašaSpotted an error? Report it

2 reports

La Vanguardia logoLa VanguardiaIndependentProgressive
The Supreme Court has rejected Trump's last-ditch attempt to disqualify 20,000 votes in California

The US Supreme Court rejected an emergency request by the Trump administration to exclude approximately 20,000 mail-in ballots in California ahead of upcoming legislative elections. The Justice Department had argued that these votes likely belonged to non-citizens, citing internal findings of potential voter fraud. However, the Court ruled that states retain constitutional authority over their election processes, preventing the federal government from interfering with state-level vote counting. A University of California study submitted to the court indicated that 42 percent of the flagged names did not appear on state voter rolls, contradicting claims of widespread fraud. The decision follows a similar rejection by an appeals court last week and effectively ends the legal avenue for the administration to challenge these specific ballots.

Bias read (Progressive): Uses emotionally charged terms like 'desperate attempt' and 'setback', frames the administration's actions as an effort to 'seed doubt' and 'interfere', and highlights evidence refuting the fraud allegations while omitting counterarguments supporting the DOJ's position.

elDiario.es logoelDiario.esIndependentProgressive
New legal setback for Trump's conspiracy theories: The Supreme Court rejects a request to overturn 20,000 votes in California before the midterm elections

The US Supreme Court rejected a last-minute appeal by the Trump administration seeking to invalidate approximately 20,000 mail-in votes in California ahead of the mid-term legislative elections. Federal authorities argued these ballots should be discarded pending citizenship verification, while California officials maintained the data used to identify non-citizens was highly unreliable and likely included many legal citizens. This decision followed a series of recent judicial defeats for the administration, including a ruling by a DC district court judge who stated that the executive branch’s interference violated the constitutional clause reserving election rules to states and Congress. During related hearings, a Department of Justice attorney acknowledged to a federal judge that there was a high rate of error in the agency's voter identification data. The article notes that the administration has faced significant criticism for introducing these demands weeks before the election using a dataset that its own department admits is not entirely reliable.

Bias read (Progressive): The headline labels the legal challenge as 'conspiracy theories' and the body emphasizes the unreliability of the government's data alongside judicial rebukes, framing the administration's actions as illegitimate and flawed rather than presenting a balanced view of the citizenship verification concerns.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories