ON
← Back to feed
Skinny is the new skinny: how body extremes reflect the zeitgeist
Australia🏛️ PoliticsLean Progressive15 days ago

Skinny is the new skinny: how body extremes reflect the zeitgeist

The article discusses the growing trend of extreme body ideals in contemporary society, focusing on both men and women. It highlights how men are embracing 'looksmaxxing', a practice involving the use of peptides and other methods to achieve a more muscular, imposing physique, while women are increasingly adopting an ultra-skinny aesthetic, often portrayed as aspirational through social media and celebrity culture. This shift is contrasted with the earlier body positivity movement, which celebrated diverse body types. The article critiques these trends as reflecting broader societal polarization, particularly in relation to gender norms and physical appearance. It references US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's controversial proposal to test military personnel for testosterone levels, suggesting this reflects a broader cultural obsession with physicality and performance.

US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has drawn criticism for announcing plans to test all male military personnel aged 30 and older for testosterone levels, a move perceived by many as reinforcing rigid masculine ideals within the armed forces. The announcement came after Hegseth had already faced scrutiny over his role in escalating tensions with Iran during President Donald Trump's administration. In a video posted to X, titled “The High-T Department of War,” Hegseth stated that “under the supervision of our world-class medical professionals,” troops would undergo annual assessments to ensure optimal performance through hormone regulation. His remarks included the promise of hormone replacement therapy for those with low testosterone levels, aiming to restore their “natural” function. Critics argue that such policies could undermine troop morale and send a troubling message to adversaries, while also marginalizing women in the military, especially given Hegseth’s history of resisting promotions for high-ranking female officers and individuals of color. Meanwhile, pop star Ariana Grande has become the focus of intense public discussion following the release of her music video for her new song Petal. In the video, Grande appears extremely thin, with visible bones along her shoulders, evoking imagery reminiscent of a child suffering from severe malnutrition. The narrative follows a struggling actress repeatedly rejected by a panel of unattractive studio executives for being “not good enough.” The video concludes with her returning to the audition room armed with a chainsaw, brutally killing the men. This stark contrast, between seeking validation and violent retaliation, has sparked widespread debate about body image and societal expectations. Fans have expressed concern over her gaunt appearance, leading to numerous articles in major publications questioning the boundaries of commenting on women’s bodies, even when framed as health concerns. Grande recently issued a statement indicating she will be taking a step back from public visibility. The cultural shift toward extreme body standards is evident in both genders. Men are increasingly adopting the “clavicular” physique, characterized by a narrow frame and defined musculature, often achieved through supplements and rigorous training regimens. This trend, referred to as “looksmaxxing,” is reflected in celebrity culture, where figures like Grande are celebrated for their extreme thinness, typically attributed to fitness routines and dietary restrictions. On the other hand, men are also embracing hyper-masculine aesthetics, emphasizing broad shoulders and sharp facial features, often through cosmetic procedures and performance-enhancing drugs. These divergent trends highlight a broader societal preoccupation with physicality, driven by media representation and evolving beauty norms. The phenomenon of extreme body ideals is not isolated to the entertainment industry. Political figures are also under pressure to conform to specific physical standards. Recently, the Times of London published an article examining the “mini-paunch” of newly appointed UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham. While noting that Burnham is described as “slim and fit” and has participated in marathons, the piece highlighted his struggle to maintain a desired physique despite his efforts. Such commentary underscores how public figures are scrutinized for their appearances, reflecting a society where physical presentation is increasingly intertwined with political legitimacy. The convergence of these trends suggests a growing polarization in societal values regarding body image. What was once a movement advocating for self-acceptance and diverse body types has evolved into a dichotomy where both extreme thinness and muscularity are celebrated. This shift raises questions about the influence of media, celebrity culture, and political discourse on individual perceptions of health and attractiveness. As these extremes continue to shape public consciousness, the implications for mental health, self-esteem, and social norms remain a pressing concern. In response to mounting scrutiny, Ariana Grande has chosen to step back from public visibility, signaling a possible retreat from the spotlight. Her decision reflects the complex pressures placed on celebrities to meet aesthetic expectations, even as they navigate personal and professional challenges. Meanwhile, the ongoing debates around body standards in politics and the military illustrate how deeply ingrained these issues are in contemporary society. As the conversation continues, the impact of these cultural shifts on individuals and communities will likely remain a topic of sustained interest and analysis.

Go to the primary sources (5)

The official sources this coverage is built on. Read them directly to bypass framing.

3 reports

The Age logoThe AgeIndependentProgressiveFactual 30Objective 2015 days ago
Skinny is the new skinny: how body extremes reflect the zeitgeist

The article discusses the growing trend of extreme body ideals among both men and women, linking it to broader societal and political shifts. It critiques U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's controversial decision to test military personnel for testosterone levels, suggesting it reflects a broader cultural emphasis on physical optimization and exclusion of women. The piece contrasts this with the 'body positivity' movement of the late 2000s, arguing that the current trend has swung toward extreme thinness, particularly among men seeking muscular definition through methods like 'looksmaxx' and peptides. It references Ariana Grande's music video, where she portrays an extremely thin figure, as an example of this aesthetic. The article implies that these trends mirror increasing polarization in American society.

Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the military's focus on testosterone and physical optimization as exclusionary and politically motivated, criticizing Hegseth's policies and actions. It highlights systemic biases against women and people of color within the military, aligning with progressive critiques of power.

Why factuality (30): This article is incomplete and continues where the previous one left off. It similarly misrepresents the primary source document by linking the testosterone testing policy to unrelated topics and making false claims about targeting male troops and excluding women. It also includes unverified allegat

Why objectivity (20): The article maintains a highly biased and hostile tone towards Pete Hegseth, using emotionally charged language and making unsubstantiated claims. It fails to present a balanced view of the policy and instead focuses on attacking Hegseth personally.

The Sydney Morning Herald logoThe Sydney Morning HeraldIndependentProgressiveFactual 30Objective 2015 days ago
Skinny is the new skinny: how body extremes reflect the zeitgeist

The article discusses the growing trend of extreme body ideals in contemporary society, focusing on both men and women. It highlights how men are embracing 'looksmaxxing', a practice involving the use of peptides and other methods to achieve a more muscular, imposing physique, while women are increasingly adopting an ultra-skinny aesthetic, often portrayed as aspirational through social media and celebrity culture. This shift is contrasted with the earlier body positivity movement, which celebrated diverse body types. The article critiques these trends as reflecting broader societal polarization, particularly in relation to gender norms and physical appearance. It references US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's controversial proposal to test military personnel for testosterone levels, suggesting this reflects a broader cultural obsession with physicality and performance.

Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the discussion around body image and physical standards within a broader critique of societal polarization and gender dynamics, emphasizing the exclusionary nature of certain policies and cultural trends. It criticizes the focus on physical appearance in both military and civilian

Why factuality (30): The article misrepresents the primary source document by attributing the testosterone testing policy to a 'unnecessary Iran war' and linking it to Ariana Grande's weight comments, which are unrelated. It also incorrectly frames the policy as targeting 'male troops' exclusively and implies exclusions

Why objectivity (20): The article exhibits strong bias and hostility toward Pete Hegseth, using emotionally charged language and making unfounded accusations. It presents a one-sided narrative that lacks balance and neutrality.

news.com.au logonews.com.auIndependentCenterFactual 5Objective 1015 days ago
NEWS OF THE WEEK: Ariana Grande to ‘step back’ amid scrutiny over her weight

The article reports that Ariana Grande has decided to 'step back' from public activities due to increased scrutiny regarding her weight. The piece highlights the growing societal pressure on celebrities, particularly women, to maintain a certain body type. It suggests that this decision reflects broader cultural issues surrounding body image and media influence. While the article does not provide specific details about Grande's plans or the extent of the scrutiny, it frames the situation within the context of ongoing discussions about body positivity and celebrity standards.

Bias read (Center): The article presents the issue of weight scrutiny in a balanced manner, focusing on societal pressures rather than taking a clear ideological stance. It does not overtly criticize either the media or the public for their behavior, nor does it advocate for any particular political viewpoint. The tone

Why factuality (5): This article is entirely unrelated to the primary source document about the US military's testosterone testing program. It discusses Ariana Grande's weight and body image issues, which is a completely different topic. Therefore, it cannot be assessed for factual accuracy regarding the military polic

Why objectivity (10): The article is not about the military testosterone testing program and thus does not exhibit bias or objectivity issues related to the subject. However, it is irrelevant to the event being scored.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories