Health Minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill has expressed a desire for all affected groups to participate in the scoping phase of a proposed statutory inquiry into the care provided by Children’s Health Ireland (CHI). This inquiry aims to investigate the treatment of children with conditions such as scoliosis, spina bifida, and hip dysplasia. However, tensions have arisen as two major advocacy organizations have withdrawn from the process, citing concerns over transparency and inclusivity.
The scoping exercise, initiated in March 2026, involves identifying the specific areas and issues that the eventual inquiry should address. Remy Farrell SC was appointed as the independent facilitator tasked with gathering input from various stakeholders. Initially, the focus was on scoliosis and spina bifida, but the scope has since expanded to include hip dysplasia. Despite these efforts, some families and advocacy groups remain skeptical about the process.
Two prominent advocacy groups, the Spina Bifida & Hydrocephalus Paediatric Advocacy Group and the Scoliosis Advocacy Network, have decided to step back from the scoping exercise. These groups collectively represent over 900 families affected by the alleged shortcomings in CHI’s services. Their decision follows frustrations regarding the lack of transparency and the withholding of critical documents related to CHI’s operations. They argue that the current approach does not adequately reflect the needs and priorities of the families involved.
Critics have pointed out that the inquiry process appears to prioritize institutional interests over the welfare of the children and their families. Social Democrats TD Padraig Rice, who chairs the Oireachtas Health Committee, criticized the situation as a “mess of the Minister of Health’s own making.” He emphasized the importance of uncovering the serious failures at CHI, including instances of unnecessary surgeries, unauthorized orthopedic procedures, the use of non-medical devices without informed consent, and the poor management of waiting lists.
During a recent visit to a new surgical hub in Swords, Minister MacNeill reiterated her commitment to ensuring that all affected groups are included in the inquiry process. She noted that while several advocacy groups have engaged with the facilitator, one group has not participated. Nevertheless, she assured that the facilitator remains open to dialogue with any interested party and has requested an extension to the scope of the inquiry to include representatives of parents of children with hip dysplasia.
Despite these assurances, concerns persist among families and advocates. They highlight the absence of crucial internal CHI reports that could provide vital insights into the organization’s practices. Some parents feel that the inquiry lacks the depth necessary to fully understand the systemic issues that have plagued CHI over the years. For instance, Gillian Sherratt, the mother of Harvey Morrison, who passed away in July 2023 after prolonged delays in receiving spinal surgery, voiced her disappointment with the current state of the inquiry. She emphasized the need for a thorough and unbiased investigation that prioritizes the well-being of children and prevents similar tragedies from occurring again.
As the inquiry moves forward, the challenge lies in balancing the diverse perspectives and demands of all stakeholders. Ensuring that the final inquiry is both comprehensive and equitable will require ongoing engagement and collaboration among the government, healthcare providers, advocacy groups, and most importantly, the families affected by CHI’s practices. The outcome of this process will not only determine the accountability of CHI but also shape future policies aimed at safeguarding the health and rights of vulnerable children.
3 reports
RTÉ NewsState / PublicCenterFactual 85Objective 7015 days agoFamilies affected by issues at Children's Health Ireland (CHI) have expressed concerns to the Irish Minister for Health and opposition politicians regarding the transparency and scope of an upcoming inquiry into the organization. Two advocacy groups, representing over 900 families, argue that the current scoping process does not adequately address their needs or include critical information. They claim that unpublished internal CHI reports are being overlooked, undermining the potential effectiveness of the inquiry. Gillian Sherratt, whose son Harvey Morrison died in 2023 after delays in receiving spinal surgery, criticized the inquiry for appearing focused on protecting CHI rather than addressing systemic failures. Harvey had been removed from a waiting list without parental consent, leading to significant delays in treatment and raising questions about the handling of his case.
Bias read (Center): The article presents multiple perspectives from affected families and highlights their criticisms of the inquiry process without overtly favoring one side. It includes direct quotes from family members and mentions the concerns raised without editorializing or biased language. The framing remains on
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 70): This article accurately reports the concerns raised by families and the withdrawal of advocacy groups. It includes direct quotes from Gillian Sherratt and mentions the lack of transparency regarding internal CHI reports. However, the tone leans slightly towards criticism of the government, which aff
RTÉ NewsState / PublicCenterFactual 80Objective 7514 days ago Minister calls on all groups to engage with CHI inquiryMinister for Health Jennifer Carroll MacNeill has urged all affected groups to engage with the independent facilitator, Remy Farrell SC, who is conducting a scoping exercise for a potential statutory inquiry into issues at Children's Health Ireland (CHI). The facilitator has contacted multiple stakeholders, including patient advocates, CHI, HSE management, and the Department of Health. However, two advocacy groups representing over 900 families have criticized the process as flawed and stated they cannot support it. The minister emphasized that no formal inquiry has been committed to by the government and that the facilitator is examining possible issues, existing reviews, and methods for conducting the inquiry. Parents and advocacy groups have raised concerns about unpublished internal CHI reports not being considered and expressed frustration over lack of communication and transparency.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both the government's position through Minister MacNeill and the criticisms from advocacy groups without overtly favoring either side. It includes direct quotes from both parties involved, providing a balanced view of the situation without apparent bias in language or emphasis.
Why these scores (Factual 80 · Objective 75): The article accurately conveys the minister's call for engagement with the independent facilitator and notes the withdrawal of two groups. It clarifies that the government has not formally committed to an inquiry yet. The tone is somewhat neutral but shows a slight bias toward the government positio
TheJournal.ieIndependentCenterFactual 75Objective 8014 days agoHealth Minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill has expressed a desire for all affected groups to participate in the scoping exercise for a statutory inquiry into the care provided by Children’s Health Ireland (CHI) for children with conditions such as scoliosis, spina bifida, and hip dysplasia. Two advocacy groups, representing over 900 families, have withdrawn from the process due to concerns about transparency and access to relevant documents. The inquiry, set to begin in November 2025, aims to investigate past issues including unnecessary surgeries, unapproved treatments, and management of waiting lists. The independent facilitator, Remy Farrell SC, has sought input from multiple groups and has expanded the scope to include hip dysplasia. However, some families remain dissatisfied with the current process.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both the government's position and the criticisms from advocacy groups and opposition figures. It includes direct quotes from the Health Minister, the chair of the Oireachtas Health Committee, and mentions the withdrawal of advocacy groups without taking a stance on their claims
Why these scores (Factual 75 · Objective 80): The article provides accurate details about the withdrawal of two advocacy groups from the scoping exercise, the inclusion of hip dysplasia, and the timeline for the inquiry. However, it lacks specific dates beyond 'November 2025' and does not clarify whether the government has officially committed
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter
Ireland
