Liverpool, Man City face questions in new era without Mo Salah, Pep Guardiola

Liverpool and Manchester City find themselves at a crossroads as they begin their respective campaigns without two of the most influential figures in Premier League history, Mohamed Salah and Pep Guardiola. The absence of these icons marks the start of a new chapter for both clubs, one defined by uncertainty and transition. Salah’s departure from Liverpool in August ended an eight-season tenure that saw him become one of the most decorated players in the club’s storied history. The Egyptian forward, who joined from Roma for £36 million in 2017, scored 257 goals in 442 appearances, earning him a place among the top scorers in Liverpool’s history. His contributions were instrumental in two Premier League titles, a Champions League victory, and multiple domestic cups. However, his exit was marred by tension with manager Arne Slot, who reportedly cast doubt on his future. Salah’s final season saw him score just seven league goals as Liverpool finished fifth, marking the end of an era for the club. Guardiola’s tenure at Manchester City came to a close after a record-breaking 11-year spell that included six Premier League titles, a Champions League triumph, and 20 major honors. The Spanish tactician, who took charge in 2016, led City to unprecedented dominance, cementing their position as England’s dominant force. Yet, the final two seasons under his leadership were marked by challenges. Guardiola struggled to maintain the intensity needed to challenge Arsenal, who claimed the title by seven points. His departure was also influenced by internal turmoil, including the resignation of his long-time director of football, Txiki Begiristain, in 2025. Despite these setbacks, Guardiola remained committed to the club, citing loyalty and the need to rebuild a squad that had lost key players such as Kevin De Bruyne, Ederson, Kyle Walker, and Riyad Mahrez. As the new season begins, both clubs face the daunting task of adapting without their legendary figures. Manchester City will open their campaign on Sunday with a match against Bournemouth, marking Enzo Maresca’s debut as Guardiola’s successor. Maresca, who previously worked alongside Guardiola during their treble-winning 2022-23 season, brings familiarity with the club’s system but lacks the extensive managerial pedigree of his predecessor. At 46, Maresca has limited experience beyond stints at Chelsea, Leicester, and Parma, presenting a challenge in leading City through its ongoing rebuild. Liverpool, meanwhile, will welcome Newcastle United on Monday under the guidance of new manager Andoni Iraola. The Basque coach, known for his defensive expertise, faces the difficult task of replacing Salah, whose impact extended beyond mere statistics. Iraola hopes that Swedish striker Alexander Isak can step up following a frustrating first season plagued by injuries. With Salah’s departure, the Reds will need more than just a replacement, they will require a cultural shift to fill the void left by one of the most beloved players in their history. Both clubs also contend with external pressures. City continues to navigate legal issues stemming from alleged financial misconduct, a situation that has lingered for years without resolution. Meanwhile, Liverpool’s management has faced scrutiny over its handling of Salah’s exit and the broader implications for the club’s identity. As the season unfolds, the true test for both teams will be whether they can emerge stronger from these transitions, proving that legacy alone is not enough to guarantee sustained success.