ON
← Back to feed
Hawthorn forgot about their women. Carlton showed what ‘one club’ actually means
Australia⚽ SportsProgressiveOverlooked by conservatives11 days ago

Hawthorn forgot about their women. Carlton showed what ‘one club’ actually means

The article discusses the contrasting approaches of two Australian Football League (AFL) clubs, Hawthorn and Carlton, in supporting their women's teams. The AFLW season has gained momentum, with a focus on expanding visibility for women's football. Hawthorn, despite having a successful women's team, failed to promote their upcoming AFLW game, instead emphasizing their men's match against Collingwood. This contrasts with Carlton, which demonstrated a unified 'one club' ethos by integrating both men's and women's teams in promotional efforts and on-field support. Carlton's actions included joint social media campaigns, shared celebrations, and mutual encouragement between genders, highlighting a more inclusive approach. The article critiques Hawthorn's lack of promotion for their women's team while praising Carlton's commitment to gender equality within the club.

Sydney confirmed their place in the finals with a commanding 36-point victory over Essendon at the MCG, securing two home finals and guaranteeing a spot in the upcoming grand final series. The Swans, already holding second place on the ladder, extended their lead with a dominant performance, finishing with a 36-point margin. This win ensures they will host the next two preliminary finals, with their likely opponent being the reigning back-to-back premiers, the Brisbane Lions. The match started with a blistering pace, as Sydney amassed nine goals compared to Essendon’s three in the first quarter, leading by 37 points at halftime. Key contributors included Charlie Curnow, who added three goals to his Coleman Medal-winning tally, and Chad Warner, who chipped in with three majors. Errol Gulden, the Swans’ star midfielder, recorded 47 touches, surpassing his career best of 42, and showed his intent to continue his stellar form. Logan McDonald was instrumental in maintaining the lead, contributing two score involvements, while Jai Serong added a crucial long-range goal. Star midfielder Isaac Heeney expressed excitement about the possibility of returning to the MCG for a potential grand final, stating, “I think our game style suits [the MCG],” and emphasizing the team’s preparation for such a scenario. Meanwhile, the AFL’s wildcard round saw a dramatic twist as Carlton secured a draw against the Western Bulldogs, earning a wildcard berth and continuing their improbable resurgence under interim coach Josh Fraser. The 12.10 (82) draw at Marvel Stadium meant Carlton had 10 wins and a draw from 13 matches, locking them into September action and eliminating St Kilda and Greater Western Sydney from finals contention. The game reached a tense climax in the final moments, with a controversial goal from Francis Evans leveling the score. Despite the confusion surrounding a mark by Wade Derksen, the Blues maintained control and preserved the draw. Fraser praised the team’s resilience, calling the result a “collective effort.” He emphasized the importance of the players’ commitment to improvement and growth, noting, “The players deserve an enormous amount of credit for the resilience they’ve shown.” The draw also highlighted the team’s defensive strength, with 146 marks and 310 uncontested possessions recorded during the match. Will Hayward, who landed a spectacular mark on Ryley Sanders, suffered an injury but remained optimistic about his recovery. The outcome of the draw significantly bolstered Fraser’s standing as a potential permanent coach, with his success under pressure strengthening his case for the role. Fraser, who initially stated he wasn’t interested in coaching beyond this season, now faces increased expectations. His leadership has transformed Carlton from a struggling team to one on the verge of a finals appearance. The club’s management will soon decide whether to extend Fraser’s tenure, considering his achievements and the positive momentum he has generated. Fans have rallied behind Fraser, chanting “Fraaaser” after recent victories, reflecting growing confidence in his ability to lead the team moving forward. In contrast, Melbourne’s premiership ambitions faced a setback following the suspension of star forward Jacob van Rooyen for three matches. Van Rooyen’s reckless hit on Port Adelaide’s Aliir Aliir during a critical moment in the match resulted in a major ban. The incident occurred in the second quarter, with van Rooyen making heavy contact with Aliir’s head, causing the latter to be sidelined for some time. Match review officer Michael Christian ruled the act as careless conduct, severe impact, and high contact, leading to the suspension. With one game remaining in the home-and-away season, van Rooyen is likely to miss Melbourne’s first final since 2023. The Demons, who defeated Port Adelaide 76 points to zero, will have until Monday lunchtime to decide whether to appeal the decision. The loss of van Rooyen adds to the challenges facing the club as they navigate the final stretch of the season. The AFL’s wildcard system, once viewed skeptically, has proven its value with Carlton’s inclusion. While critics argued the format rewarded mediocrity, the Blues’ turnaround has demonstrated its merit. Their ability to secure a wildcard spot through a draw underscores the competitive nature of the league and the unpredictability of outcomes. As the season nears its conclusion, the focus shifts toward the upcoming finals, with several teams vying for a place in the grand final. The Swans’ dominance, Carlton’s resurgence, and the uncertainty surrounding Melbourne’s future highlight the dynamic landscape of the AFL. With multiple games remaining, the race for the top spots continues, setting the stage for an exciting conclusion to the season.

3 reports

ABC News (Australia) logoABC News (Australia)State / PublicCenterFactual 65Objective 7014 days ago
Blues start AFLW season with 26-point win over Saints

Carlton began the 2026 AFLW season with a 26-point victory over St Kilda, winning 9.12 (66) to 6.4 (40). The match saw Carlton maintain control despite a late fightback from St Kilda, who managed to close the gap to 11 points in the final minutes. The game took place at Docklands Stadium as part of a double-header season format, drawing a strong crowd of over 20,000. Key performers included Lily Goss, who kicked two goals, and young player Poppy Scholz, who opened the scoring. Despite injuries to several players, Carlton's midfield dominance helped secure the win.

Bias read (Center): The article reports on a sports event without any political implications. It focuses solely on the performance and outcomes of the AFLW game, presenting information objectively without taking sides or expressing ideological preferences.

Why factuality (65): The article contains incomplete and fragmented information about the AFLW season and the match between St Kilda and Carlton. It lacks coherence and fails to provide a complete picture of the event, making it less reliable compared to other sources.

Why objectivity (70): The tone is somewhat disjointed, with limited contextual information that may affect the reader's understanding.

The Age logoThe AgeIndependentCenterFactual 65Objective 6011 days ago
Hawthorn forgot about their women. Carlton showed what ‘one club’ actually means

The article discusses the contrasting approaches of two Australian Football League (AFL) clubs, Hawthorn and Carlton, in supporting their women's teams. The AFLW season has gained momentum, with a focus on expanding visibility for women's football. Hawthorn, despite having a successful women's team, failed to promote their upcoming AFLW game, instead emphasizing their men's match against Collingwood. This contrasts with Carlton, which demonstrated a unified 'one club' ethos by integrating both men's and women's teams in promotional efforts and on-field support. Carlton's actions included joint social media campaigns, shared celebrations, and mutual encouragement between genders, highlighting a more inclusive approach. The article critiques Hawthorn's lack of promotion for their women's team while praising Carlton's commitment to gender equality within the club.

Bias read (Center): The article focuses on sports and does not engage with political issues, policies, or figures directly. It provides a balanced comparison between two sports clubs without taking a stance on broader societal or political matters.

Why factuality (65): The article reports on the AFLW season start, mentions Hawthorn's lack of promotion for their women's team, and references Carlton's 'one club' approach. While these points are consistent with the cross-source consensus, the article includes opinionated language ('What a pity the club forgot about i

Why objectivity (60): The tone is critical of Hawthorn and praises Carlton, using emotionally charged phrases like 'What a pity' and implying internal dissatisfaction at Hawthorn. The article frames the issue as a failure rather than presenting a balanced view.

The Sydney Morning Herald logoThe Sydney Morning HeraldIndependentProgressiveFactual 65Objective 6011 days ago
Hawthorn forgot about their women. Carlton showed what ‘one club’ actually means

The article discusses the AFLW (Australian Football League Women's) season starting with renewed momentum, highlighting the contrast between two clubs, Hawthorn and Carlton. Hawthorn, despite achieving a record membership of 90,000, failed to promote their women's home season opener, focusing instead on their men's game against Collingwood. This oversight drew internal criticism. In contrast, Carlton demonstrated a 'one club' approach by integrating their men's and women's teams, showcasing unity through shared activities like learning dance routines and showing support during games. The piece critiques the lack of prioritization for women's football at Hawthorn while praising Carlton's inclusive practices.

Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the disparity in attention and promotion between Hawthorn's men's and women's teams as a failure, implying a systemic issue within the club's management. It contrasts this with Carlton's proactive integration efforts, suggesting a more progressive stance. The emphasis on the 'one-

Why factuality (65): Similar to Article 0, this article aligns with the cross-source consensus regarding Hawthorn's lack of promotion for their women's team and Carlton's integration efforts. However, it also uses subjective language and omits details about broader context or alternative perspectives.

Why objectivity (60): The article maintains the same critical tone towards Hawthorn and positive framing of Carlton. It uses similar emotive language and fails to present multiple viewpoints, maintaining a one-sided narrative.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories