An IDF veteran who once self-immolated in protest over inadequate support for wounded soldiers has called on the Knesset to prioritize combat soldiers over Torah study as a foundational value of the state. Itzik Saidyan, whose dramatic act of self-sacrifice in 2021 drew national attention to the struggles of veterans, addressed the Knesset House Committee on Sunday as it debated a controversial proposed Basic Law declaring Torah study a fundamental value of Israel. This bill aims to protect ultra-Orthodox men from being prosecuted for avoiding military service, despite ongoing concerns about a critical shortage of soldiers in the IDF.
Saidyan, a former combatant who served in the Golani Infantry Brigade, delivered a passionate plea to the committee, emphasizing the urgent need for the state to recognize and support those who have faced the horrors of war firsthand. He recounted how he and others who served on the front lines have endured trauma, loss, and physical injuries that have left lasting scars on both their bodies and psyches. Saidyan described how these soldiers, often just a small percentage of the population, bear the brunt of conflict and sacrifice, while others are exempt from service.
In his speech, Saidyan criticized the focus on Torah study as a foundational value, stating that while he respects the importance of religious education, the immediate priority should be the welfare of those who have risked their lives in battle. He argued that the state must show tangible appreciation for these individuals, ensuring they receive proper care, recognition, and support. Saidyan emphasized that the current system fails to adequately address the needs of wounded soldiers, many of whom suffer from post-traumatic stress disorder and require long-term medical and psychological assistance.
The controversy surrounding the proposed Basic Law stems from the fact that it would effectively shield ultra-Orthodox men from being drafted into the military, despite the IDF’s ongoing struggle with manpower shortages. Approximately 80,000 ultra-Orthodox men aged between 18 and 24 are currently eligible for military service but have not enlisted. Critics argue that the bill represents a direct challenge to the authority of the High Court, which has previously ruled that yeshiva students must be conscripted into the military.
The Knesset’s decision to advance the bill comes amid widespread protests from the Haredi community, who have staged demonstrations against the arrest of draft dodgers. These protests have led to traffic disruptions and confrontations with law enforcement. Meanwhile, the IDF has expressed deep concern over the potential impact of the bill on its ability to maintain adequate troop levels, especially as the war continues to escalate.
IDF Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Eyal Zamir reiterated the need for the government to prioritize soldiers and their families in policy decisions, stressing that they represent the country’s most vital resource. He called for increased investment in military infrastructure, healthcare, and support services for active-duty personnel and veterans. In addition, Brig. Gen. Shay Tayeb, head of the IDF Personnel Directorate’s Planning and Personnel Management Division, warned that without significant reforms to conscription laws, the military will face a severe manpower crisis in the coming years.
Tayeb highlighted the urgency of extending mandatory military service for men from 30 months back to 36 months, as the current policy is leading to a gap in available personnel. He noted that the first group of soldiers enlisted under the reduced term will be released in early 2027, creating a vacuum in the armed forces unless the law is amended. The IDF has taken some measures to bolster its ranks, such as forming new reserve units and integrating more members of the ultra-Orthodox community, but these efforts have proven insufficient to meet the demands of prolonged warfare.
The debate over the Basic Law has sparked intense political divisions, with even members of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s coalition expressing reservations about the bill. Some lawmakers have openly opposed it, citing concerns about its economic implications and its potential to undermine national unity. The Finance Ministry has raised alarms about the possible financial burden of the law, warning that it could lead to higher taxes and negatively affect the economy.
As the Knesset moves forward with discussions on the bill, the voices of veterans like Saidyan remain a powerful reminder of the human cost of war and the need for policies that reflect the sacrifices made by those who serve. Their calls for recognition and support echo through the halls of power, demanding that the state place the needs of its combatants at the forefront of its priorities.
11 reports
The Jerusalem PostIndependentConservativeFactual 95Objective 857 days agoThe Knesset passed the Basic Law: Torah Study bill in its first reading, backed by ultra-Orthodox (haredi) parties and supported by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. The bill seeks to enshrine Torah study as a fundamental value in Israeli society, granting yeshiva students continued state benefits regardless of military service, which critics argue could encourage draft evasion during the IDF's manpower crisis. The measure passed with 63 votes in favor and 53 against, following weeks of haredi-led efforts to pressure Netanyahu's coalition to expedite legislation. The bill will undergo further debates and require additional approvals before becoming law. Coalition members, including Likud and Religious Zionist lawmakers, openly opposed the measure, citing concerns over national security and resource allocation.
Bias read (Conservative): The article frames the bill as a significant legislative achievement backed by Netanyahu and haredi leaders, emphasizing its alignment with traditional Jewish values and the support from key political figures. While it presents opposition from coalition members, the narrative leans toward validating
Why these scores (Factual 95 · Objective 85): Accurately reports the Knesset passing the Torah study bill, including key details like the vote count, supporters, and context around the haredi parties' push. Maintains neutrality in presenting facts.
The Times of IsraelIndependentCenterFactual 90Objective 853 days agoIDF veteran Itzik Saidyan, who self-immolated in 2021 to draw attention to the struggles of wounded soldiers, addressed a Knesset committee advocating for prioritizing combat soldiers over Torah study as a foundational state value. His remarks coincided with debate over a proposed Basic Law that would exempt ultra-Orthodox men from mandatory military service, a move opposed by legal experts and seen as exacerbating Israel's ongoing manpower crisis. Saidyan emphasized the sacrifices of combat soldiers, many of whom suffer physical and psychological injuries, arguing that the state must recognize and support them above other priorities. The Defense Ministry has raised concerns about the strain on its rehabilitation system due to the increasing number of wounded soldiers.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both perspectives: Saidyan's call to prioritize combat soldiers and the controversy surrounding the proposed Basic Law protecting ultra-Orthodox draft dodgers. It does not favor one side through loaded language, one-sided sourcing, or omission of context. The framing remains non
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 85): Reports on the IDF chief's criticism of the Torah study bill, providing context about the manpower crisis and political tensions. Balanced and factual with minimal bias.
The Times of IsraelIndependentCenterFactual 90Objective 806 days ago IDF chief says soldiers must be priority after Basic Law on Torah study advancesIDF Chief of Staff Lt. Gen. Eyal Zamir emphasized that soldiers should be prioritized in state policies following the Knesset's approval of a controversial Basic Law designating Torah study as a foundational Israeli value. This law has sparked significant debate, with critics claiming it aims to exempt ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students from military service by legally enshrining Torah study as a national value. The law comes amid ongoing tensions between the government and the Haredi community, which has staged mass protests against the arrest of draft dodgers. Meanwhile, the IDF faces severe personnel shortages due to reduced mandatory service periods and increased combat demands. Senior military officials have called for legislative action to address these challenges, including extending mandatory service and reforming reserve duty laws.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both perspectives on the controversy surrounding the Basic Law and highlights the concerns raised by the IDF regarding personnel shortages. It does not exhibit overtly biased language or one-sided sourcing, providing a balanced overview of the situation.
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 80): Reports on the Knesset's move to freeze arrests of draft evaders, including key figures and motivations. Provides context but includes some subjective analysis of the political implications.
The Jerusalem PostIndependentCenterFactual 90Objective 759 days ago Ultra-Orthodox party paralyzes Knesset votes to force through military draft exemptionsThe Ultra-Orthodox (Haredi) party United Torah Judaism (UTJ) has announced it will boycott coalition voting in the Knesset, disrupting the legislative agenda. This move comes after UTJ accused the government coalition of not advancing promised legislation quickly enough. The party is pushing for a bill that would temporarily halt arrests of Haredi draft evaders, which is scheduled for debate in the Knesset’s Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee. Additionally, a separate bill aims to enshrine Torah study in Israel’s Basic Law, a move seen by critics as encouraging draft evasion and altering the status of non-serving yeshiva students.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both the actions of the Ultra-Orthodox party and the government's response without overtly favoring either side. It includes quotes from the UTJ and mentions criticisms from opponents of the proposed legislation but does not exhibit clear biased language or one-sided sourcing.
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 75): Includes a direct quote from an IDF veteran expressing strong opinions about prioritizing combat soldiers over Torah study. While factual, the emotional tone affects objectivity.
The Jerusalem PostIndependentCenterFactual 90Objective 7510 days ago Defense Ministry backs 90-freeze on haredi draft evader arrests as Israel faces coalition crisisDefense Minister Israel Katz proposed a 90-day freeze on arresting haredi (ultra-Orthodox) draft evaders amid a political crisis involving the Knesset advancing legislation to enshrine Torah study in a Basic Law. This move follows pressure from haredi parties, including Shas and United Torah Judaism, which had threatened to boycott coalition votes unless their demands were met. Katz requested an urgent meeting with Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee Chair Boaz Bismuth to discuss the proposal, which was later outlined by Bismuth. The proposal would prevent arrests, investigations, or enforcement actions related to draft evasion during the 90-day period. The legislation to enshrine Torah study in a Basic Law is part of a larger effort by haredi groups to secure legal protections for their religious practices, particularly regarding military service exemptions.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both the defense minister's proposal and the haredi parties' demands without overtly favoring one side. It includes quotes from multiple stakeholders and outlines the legal and political context neutrally, avoiding loaded language or one-sided emphasis.
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 75): Factuality is high as it provides detailed information about the defense ministry's position and related political context. Objectivity is lower due to some emotionally charged language regarding the impact of arrests on enlistment efforts.
The Times of IsraelIndependentConservativeFactual 85Objective 807 days ago Contentious Basic Law on Torah study, aimed at shielding draft evaders, passes 1st readingThe Knesset passed the first reading of a controversial Basic Law that declares Torah study a foundational value of the State of Israel, aiming to protect draft evading ultra-Orthodox yeshiva students from legal repercussions. Sponsored by ultra-Orthodox lawmakers Moshe Gafni and Yaakov Asher, and supported by the Shas party, the bill seeks to exempt religious students from military service obligations. This follows a stalled coalition-backed enlistment bill and reflects ongoing tensions between ultra-Orthodox parties and the governing coalition led by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. The legislation faces significant criticism, including from within the coalition, for potentially undermining court decisions mandating the conscription of ultra-Orthodox youth. The bill will undergo further review before final approval.
Bias read (Conservative): The article frames the legislation as a response to perceived threats to religious freedoms and highlights opposition from secular and centrist factions within the coalition. It emphasizes the ultra-Orthodox parties' stance while downplaying concerns about potential legal loopholes and the erosionof
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 80): Summarizes the political situation and legislative agenda, providing context about the Torah study bill and related bills. Neutral in tone but leans slightly towards highlighting controversy.
The Times of IsraelIndependentCenterFactual 85Objective 8010 days ago Daily Briefing June 29: Can anyone build a coalition without the Haredi and Arab parties?The Times of Israel's Daily Briefing discusses the Israeli Knesset's upcoming agenda, focusing on the controversial proposed Basic Law that would enshrine Torah study as a foundational value of the state, backed by ultra-Orthodox parties aiming to exempt yeshiva students from military service. Other contentious bills include changes to the attorney general's authority and a communications bill that could impact media independence. The briefing also examines potential political alliances ahead of Israel's October election, particularly between Benny Gantz's Blue and White party, Yoaz Hendel's Reservists party, and Dedy Simhi, noting unresolved tensions. It concludes with an overview of key political figures like Gadi Eisenkot, Naftali Bennett, and Benjamin Netanyahu amid ongoing coalition negotiations.
Bias read (Center): The article provides a balanced overview of multiple political developments in Israel, including legislative proposals and potential alliances, without overtly favoring any side. It presents facts and quotes from political analysts without evident ideological framing.
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 80): Describes the haredi parties' strategy to delay legislation and pressures on Netanyahu. Presents information objectively but includes some subjective commentary on the impact of the boycott.
The Times of IsraelIndependentConservativeFactual 85Objective 708 days ago Knesset advances Basic Law on Torah study, pushes to freeze arrests of draft dodgersThe Knesset House Committee advanced a proposed Basic Law declaring Torah study a foundational value of Israel, following a contentious debate. This legislation is part of an effort by Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) parties to secure legal protections for yeshiva students exempt from military service and to shield current draft evaders from prosecution. The bill aims to elevate the status of Torah study within Israeli law, with supporters claiming it preserves Jewish heritage and ensures recognition of religious education. Opponents, including Deputy Attorney General Avital Sompolinsky and opposition lawmakers, argue the law raises unresolved constitutional issues and represents a politically motivated attempt to bypass court decisions on mandatory military service. The legislation is set for its first plenum vote soon.
Bias read (Conservative): The article frames the legislation as a significant step toward granting special legal status to Torah study and shielding draft evaders, emphasizing support from Haredi parties and their arguments about preserving Jewish heritage. It presents criticism from opponents but does not balance the legal,
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 70): Factuality is good as it outlines the legislative action and its connection to the Haredi parties' agenda. Objectivity is somewhat lower due to quotes from political figures that contain strong opinions and potentially biased rhetoric.
The Times of IsraelIndependentCenterFactual 80Objective 7510 days ago Knesset panel to advance measure freezing arrests of Haredi draft evaders for 90 daysThe Knesset's Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, led by Boaz Bismuth, plans to advance temporary legislation that would halt the arrests of Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) draft evaders for 90 days. This move follows pressure from Defense Minister Israel Katz and Cabinet Secretary Yossi Fuchs, who both called for a moratorium on such arrests. The decision comes amid tensions between the government and Haredi parties, which have boycotted coalition legislation due to disagreements over military service exemptions for yeshiva students. The proposed measure aims to prevent further protests and disruptions caused by Haredi demonstrations against the enforcement of conscription laws. Under the plan, arrests, investigations, and legal actions related to draft evasion would be suspended for 90 days, provided the yeshiva meets specific criteria, including minimum weekly study hours.
Bias read (Center): The article presents the situation objectively, quoting multiple officials and outlining the proposed legislation without overtly favoring either side. It includes perspectives from both the government and the Haredi community, providing balanced context about the political conflict and the proposed
Why these scores (Factual 80 · Objective 75): Presents Deputy FM Haskel's criticism of the daycare law with strong emotive language. While factually correct, the tone suggests a partisan viewpoint, affecting objectivity.
HaaretzIndependent🔒CenterFactual 75Objective 8011 days agoThe article reports that Israel's Defense Minister has requested the Knesset to stop the arrest of Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) men who avoid military service. The request comes amid ongoing debates over national service obligations and religious exemptions. Haredi communities often exempt their members from mandatory conscription based on religious beliefs, leading to tensions between the state and these groups. The move by the defense minister reflects broader political and social discussions about balancing religious rights with national security needs.
Bias read (Center): The article presents the defense minister's request without overtly endorsing or criticizing the action. It frames the issue as a political and legal matter rather than taking a clear ideological stance. While the topic involves significant societal division, the reporting does not exhibit strong sl
Why these scores (Factual 75 · Objective 80): Factuality is moderate as it reports a claim from the Israeli Defense Minister without additional context or verification. Objectivity is high as it presents the statement neutrally without evident bias.
The Jerusalem PostIndependentProgressiveyesterday 'Little girls with microphones': IDF veteran slams MKs during Basic Law: Torah Study cm'tee meetingAn IDF veteran with PTSD interrupted a Knesset House Committee meeting discussing the Basic Law: Torah Study bill, accusing lawmakers of being ineffective and harmful to veterans. He criticized the bill, which allows yeshiva students who avoid military service to receive state benefits despite the IDF's manpower crisis. The bill is controversial, with even some members of Netanyahu's coalition opposing it. The legislation, backed by haredi parties and the government, aims to fast-track passage amid threats of boycotts from haredi leaders seeking to influence the legislative agenda.
Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the veteran's criticism as a moral indictment of lawmakers' behavior, emphasizing their failure to address veterans' needs. While the bill itself is presented as controversial, the narrative leans toward criticizing the political establishment for neglecting veterans, aligning ide
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter
IL
