Karnataka High Court reconstitutes KPSC probe SIT, appoints R Hitendra as chief
The Karnataka High Court has reconstituted the Special Investigation Team (SIT) tasked with probing alleged recruitment scams within the Karnataka Public Service Commission (KPSC). Senior IPS officer R Hitendra was appointed as the new head of the SIT, replacing Alok Kumar, whose appointment had been challenged by the state government due to lack of consultation. The court emphasized the need for investigative independence, explicitly barring officers involved in prior Criminal Intelligence Department (CID) probes from joining the new team. Additionally, the bench directed that the Enforcement Directorate (ED) and the SIT conduct their respective investigations in parallel and independently, requiring them to cooperate rather than compete over jurisdiction. This move follows a recent Supreme Court ruling that upheld the creation of the SIT but modified the mandate to continue existing investigations rather than starting anew.
Karnataka High Court Judge M Nagaprasanna reconstituted the Special Investigation Team probing alleged recruitment scams within the Karnataka Public Service Commission on Monday. The bench appointed senior IPS officer R Hitendra as the new SIT head, replacing Alok Kumar, a Directorate General of Police rank officer whom the state government had challenged. Additional Director General of Police Soumendu Mukherjee joined as the second senior officer, displacing Dr Divya Gopinath. Three existing members, Anup Shetty, Kushal Chouksey, and Kshama Mishra, remain on the team. This judicial action followed the Supreme Court’s October 13 ruling regarding the state government’s challenge to a September 21 high court order. The Supreme Court upheld the creation of the SIT but rejected the directive for a completely fresh investigation. Instead, the apex court directed the team to continue inquiries from the stage where the previous agency stopped. The high court judge stated that the objective is to ensure the investigation proceeds with renewed independence. He emphasized that the probe must be insulated from the shadow of its predecessor. Consequently, none of the officers associated with the earlier Criminal Investigation Department investigations can join the SIT as assistants. The bench mandated that Enforcement Directorate and SIT investigations proceed in parallel and independently within their statutory spheres. However, both agencies must cooperate. The court warned against competing assertions of jurisdiction, stating that the dual probes must complement the pursuit of truth. The Enforcement Directorate is required to report investigation progress to the high court in accordance with prior directions. Justice Nagaprasanna noted that the reconstituted team must command confidence and remain impervious to institutional or extraneous influences. The underlying cases involve specific allegations of corruption. One case concerns the recruitment of 400 veterinary officers. According to reports, 29 of the 329 selected candidates allegedly paid bribes ranging from twenty million rupees to forty million rupees to obtain entrance examination questions and answers. The second case involves the alleged illegal selection of the daughter of suspended KPSC Chairman Shivashankrappa Sahukar for a government position. These legal maneuvers stem from petitions filed by a students’ association, a Bharatiya Janata Party member of legislative assembly, and unsuccessful aspirants. They initially sought a Central Bureau of Investigation inquiry after questioning the integrity of the state police probe. The state government had objected to the initial appointment of Alok Kumar, arguing the high court failed to consult the state police chief or the executive branch. The government also contended that the high court had not identified faults in the ongoing CID work yet still ordered a new probe. Separately, the Kerala Public Service Commission faces its own scrutiny over examination irregularities. A Special Investigation Team led by Inspector General of Police S. Ajeetha Begum is examining complaints related to multiple recruitment exams. This investigation expanded after officials discovered unevaluated answer sheets from a 2023 exam for senior posts in the State Planning Board. The Kerala Crime Branch is currently handling these matters, distinct from the Karnataka proceedings described above. Both commissions are now under intense regulatory and judicial review due to allegations of manipulation and lapses in evaluation processes.
The Karnataka High Court has reconstituted the Special Investigation Team (SIT) tasked with probing alleged recruitment scams within the Karnataka Public Service Commission (KPSC). Senior IPS officer R Hitendra was appointed as the new head of the SIT, replacing Alok Kumar, whose appointment had been challenged by the state government due to lack of consultation. The court emphasized the need for investigative independence, explicitly barring officers involved in prior Criminal Intelligence Department (CID) probes from joining the new team. Additionally, the bench directed that the Enforcement Directorate (ED) and the SIT conduct their respective investigations in parallel and independently, requiring them to cooperate rather than compete over jurisdiction. This move follows a recent Supreme Court ruling that upheld the creation of the SIT but modified the mandate to continue existing investigations rather than starting anew.
Bias read (Center): The article relies exclusively on direct quotes from judicial orders and factual reporting of legal proceedings, presenting the conflict between the judiciary and state government without editorializing or favoring either side.
Why factuality (95): The article provides specific, verifiable details including names of judges, officers, and dates. It accurately reflects the legal nuances of the High Court's order regarding the separation of CID and SIT roles. While no primary source was available, the level of detail suggests high fidelity to off
Why objectivity (90): The tone is professional and journalistic. It quotes the judge directly to convey the rationale behind the decision, avoiding subjective interpretation. The framing is neutral, presenting the court's actions and the government's objection without taking sides.
The Kerala Public Service Commission (KPSC) is undergoing intense scrutiny due to allegations of manipulation and procedural lapses in various government job recruitment exams. Initial concerns arose after unevaluated answer sheets were discovered in a 2023 examination for senior positions within the State Planning Board. This incident has expanded into a broader investigation led by the state's Crime Branch. A Special Investigation Team, commanded by Inspector General of Police S. Ajeetha Begum, is currently reviewing complaints related to multiple recruitment processes. The ongoing probes aim to address claims of questionable practices and ensure transparency in the state's primary hiring mechanism.
Bias read (Center): The article relies on neutral, factual reporting of official police actions and uses standard journalistic phrasing like 'allegations' and 'scrutiny' without employing emotionally charged language or taking a partisan stance.
Why factuality (40): This article appears to describe a completely different event involving the Kerala PSC rather than the Karnataka KPSC SIT reconstitution described in Article 0. Since both articles are supposed to cover the 'same event,' this represents a fundamental factual error or mismatch in the dataset. If judg
Why objectivity (70): The writing style is neutral and informative, using standard journalistic phrasing like 'mounting scrutiny' and 'questionable practices.' However, because the subject matter seems disjointed from the primary event (Karnataka vs Kerala), the objectivity score is limited by the confusion in scope, tho
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.