Izrael je prekinil stike z visoko zunanjepolitično predstavnico Evropske unije (EU), Kajo Kallas, zaradi domnevne primerjave njegovega ravnanja v Gazi in na Zahodnem bregu z nekdanjim apartheidom v Južni Afriki. Odluka je sprejel izraelski zunanji minister Gideon Sar, ki je v svojem sporočilu na platformi X izrazil prepričanje, da Kallas "naslovila krvave obtožbe", kar je za njega neprijazno in nekonstruktno. V skladu z poročili medijev, kot so N1 Slovenija, Mladina, 24ur in Žurnal24, je Kallas med svojim obiskom Mehike predstavil izraelsko ravnanje s Palestinci kot podobno nekdanjemu apartheidu, kar je povzročilo odziv izraelske strani.
Kallas je obiskala Mehiko pred meseci, kjer je na pogovorih za zaprtimi vrati s predstavniki vlade izrazila svoje mnenje o izraelskem ravnanju v Gazi in na Zahodnem bregu. Po poročanju portala Euractiv je bilo objavljeno, da je Kallas primerjala izraelsko politiko z rasističnim režimom apartheida, ki je obstajal v Južni Afriki. Tako je izraelski zunanji minister Gideon Sar izrazil prepričanje, da je ta izjava resna in nekonstruktna, kar je povzročilo odločitev o prekinitvi stikov. Sar je opozoril, da Kallas doslej ni zanikala ali pojasnila svoje izjave, kar mu omogoča le eno možnost – prekiniti vsakršen stik z njo, dokler ne umakne krvave obtožbe.
Kallas je v svojem odzivu izpostavila potrebo po nadaljevanju dialoga med EU in Izraelom, vendar se ni opredelila do obtožbe. Na svojem profilu na platformi X je zapisala, da cenita dialog in sodelovanje ter je odprta za nadaljevanje v tem duhu, spoštljivo in konstruktivno. Prepričana je, da je rešitev dveh držav edina izvedljiva pot za vzpostavitev miru na Bližnjem vzhodu. "EU je obsodila nezakonite izraelske naselbine na Zahodnem bregu, ki doseganje tega cilja vedno bolj otežujejo. To je stališče EU," je dodala. Kljub temu je Sar kritičen do njenega odziva in opozoril, da se izogiba komentiranju obtožbe o primerjavi z apartheidom. "Zadeva je preprosta: če ste res podali te izjave, potem za njimi stojite. Če jih niste podali, to zanikajte. Dokler se zadeva ne razjasni, bo moja odločitev ostala nespremenjena," je dodal.
Odnosi med Izraelom in EU so se v zadnjih letih znatno zaostrili zaradi vojne v Gazi in nasilja izraelskih naseljencev na Zahodnem bregu. Nedavno je Kallas dejala, da bo EU na podlagi pozivov več članic preučila možnosti za omejitev trgovanja z izraelskimi naselbinami. Prav tako je opozorila, da so se nekatere članice zavzele za uvedbo sankcij proti ministru za nacionalno varnost Itamarju Ben-Gviru zaradi objave posnetka neprimernega ravnanja Izraela z aktivisti s flotilje s humanitarno pomočjo za Gazo. Te izjave so doprineli k napetosti med EU in Izraelom, kjer se razprava o statusu Palestincev in njihovem pravu postaja vse pomembnejša.
Na dvodnevnem zasedanju Evropskega sveta v Bruslju, ki je za premierja Janeza Janšo prvo, odkar je znova prevzel položaj, je bilo predmet razprave tudi vloga EU pri ohranjanju in umirjanju napetosti v regiji. Razpravljali bodo predvsem o vlogi EU pri ohranjanju oziroma nadaljnji umiritvi napetosti v regiji, potem ko sta ZDA in Iran po več kot treh mesecih spopadov v sredo podpisala dogovor o končanju vojne. V petkovi razpravi o Bližnjem vzhodu bodo govorili še o razmerah v palestinski enklavi Gaza in na zasedenem Zahodnem bregu. Janša je dejal, da ni slišal, da bi Kallas primerjala ravnanje Izraela z nekdanjim apartheidom v Južni Afriki. "Če je, pa se je motila," je povedal ob prihodu na vrh.
Te dogodke kažejo, kako kompleksno in polemljeno je trenutno razmerje med Izraelom in EU. Medtem ko Kallas trdi, da želi nadaljevati dialog, izraelska stran meni, da je njene izjave neprijazne in nekonstruktni. Sledi bo, kako bo EU odgovarjala na izraelsko odločitev, ali bo poskušala ponovno vzpostaviti stike, ali pa bo izkoristila to kot priložnost za večjo kritiko izraelske politike. Vse to bo imelo vpliv na meje med EU in Izraelom, kar bo vplivalo tudi na globalne odnose in politične strategije v regiji.
4 reports
N1 SlovenijaIndependentCenterFactual 95Objective 8515 days agoIsraeli Foreign Minister Gideon Saar announced the termination of diplomatic contacts with European Union High Representative Kaja Kallas following reports that she compared Israel's treatment of Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank to South Africa's former apartheid regime during a closed-door meeting in Mexico last month. Saar stated he would not resume contact with Kallas until she retracts what he called 'blood libel' against Israel, the only Jewish state in the world.
Bias read (Center): The article presents a factual summary of the reported statement by Kallas and the subsequent response by Israeli officials without overtly favoring either side. It does not include explicit commentary, loaded language, or selective sourcing that would indicate a clear ideological slant.
Why these scores (Factual 95 · Objective 85): The article accurately reports the claim by Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Saar that he has cut ties with Kaja Kallas due to her alleged comparison of Israel's actions to apartheid. It cites AFP as a source and includes direct quotes from Saar. The only minor deduction is that it does not explicitl
MladinaIndependentRightFactual 95Objective 7516 days agoIsrael has decided to cut ties with EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Catherine Kallas following alleged remarks she made during her visit to Mexico, where she compared Israel's actions in Gaza and the West Bank to South Africa's former apartheid regime. Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Sar stated that Kallas has not denied or clarified these comments and therefore Israel has no choice but to terminate all contact with her until she retracts the 'blood libel' she leveled against the only Jewish state in the world, which is also the only democracy in the Middle East.
Bias read (Right): The article frames Kallas' comparison of Israel's policies to apartheid as a 'blood libel,' a strong term typically used to describe false accusations against Jews. The language used by Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Sar emphasizes the severity of the accusation and portrays it as an attack on the犹
Why these scores (Factual 95 · Objective 75): High factual accuracy based on cross-source consensus. The article accurately reports Israel's decision to cut ties with Kaja Kallas over alleged comments comparing Israel to apartheid. However, the tone leans toward supporting Israel's position with phrases like 'krvave obtožbe' (bloody accusations
24ur (POP TV)IndependentRightFactual 93Objective 7015 days agoIsraeli Foreign Minister Gideon Sar has cut diplomatic ties with Estonian Prime Minister Kaja Kallas following her alleged comparison of Israel to South Africa's apartheid regime during a visit to Mexico. Sar stated that Kallas has not denied or clarified the remarks, leading to the decision to suspend contact until she retracts the accusation. Kallas has expressed willingness to continue dialogue with Israel but has not explicitly addressed the specific claim.
Bias read (Right): The article presents Israeli officials' accusations against Kallas without providing counterpoints or contextualizing her statements. It emphasizes the severing of relations due to the alleged comparison, which frames the issue as an attack on Israel's legitimacy. The tone supports the Israeli side,
Why these scores (Factual 93 · Objective 70): Factual content aligns closely with other sources. It includes direct quotes from both Sar and Kallas, providing balance. However, the article still shows a slight pro-Israel bias by emphasizing the 'responsible' nature of the accusation and not fully contextualizing Kallas’s stance.
Žurnal24IndependentRightFactual 90Objective 6515 days agoIsrael has cut ties with European Union High Representative Kaja Kallas following her comparison of Israel's treatment of Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank to South Africa's apartheid regime during a visit to Mexico. Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Sar stated that Kallas has not denied or clarified her remarks, leading to the decision to terminate all contact until she retracts the accusation. Kallas has not publicly responded to the allegations but expressed a willingness to continue dialogue with Israel.
Bias read (Right): The article frames Kallas' comments as 'serious accusations' against Israel, emphasizing the severing of ties due to her alleged comparison of Israel to an apartheid regime. The language used by Israeli officials is strong and critical of Kallas, while Kallas' response is described as non-committal.
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 65): The article presents the facts accurately but lacks nuance in reporting Kallas’s response. It repeats the Israeli government's framing of her remarks as 'bloody accusations,' which may influence reader perception. The objectivity score reflects this partial bias.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter
Slovenia
