ON
← Back to feed
‘If citizens being removed, what is purpose of SIR?’ Bombay High Court asks Election Commission
India🏛️ PoliticsCenter

‘If citizens being removed, what is purpose of SIR?’ Bombay High Court asks Election Commission

The Bombay High Court in Goa questioned the purpose of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) process conducted by the Election Commission of India (ECI), highlighting concerns that citizens might be excluded from the electoral rolls despite the SIR's intent to ensure universal voter registration. The court heard a petition from Paresh Salgaoncar and five family members whose names were removed from the electoral rolls after their Form 8 applications for changing their address were rejected. The court emphasized that the ECI has a responsibility to ensure all citizens are included in the voter list and criticized the current system for creating a 'Catch-22' scenario for voters who are unable to update their information without facing legal risks. The court pointed out that under Rule 21 of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, the ECI must consider requests for address changes based on the existing voter roll rather than a draft roll, leaving voters with limited options for rectifying errors.

The Bombay High Court has raised concerns over the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) process, questioning its purpose if citizens are being excluded from the electoral rolls. During a hearing in Goa, a division bench of Justices Amit S Jamsandekar and Valmiki Menezes challenged the Election Commission of India (ECI) on whether the SIR initiative serves any meaningful function if it results in the removal of voters. The court heard a petition filed by Paresh Salgaoncar and five family members, whose names had been deleted from the electoral rolls after their Form 8 applications for a change of address were rejected. The petitioners argued that they faced a "Catch-22" situation, as they were unable to update their information due to procedural issues. They had moved to a new house in the same Santa Cruz Assembly constituency eight years ago and followed instructions to submit Form 8. However, they were informed that their Electors Photo Identity Cards (EPICs) had been deleted, preventing further processing of their application. Their only recourse was to submit Form 6, which applies to new voters, as there was no option to review or restore the deleted EPICs through the online system. The court emphasized that the ECI has a responsibility to ensure all citizens remain on the electoral rolls. It questioned why a voter would be required to make a false declaration if they are forced to submit Form 6, noting that such a declaration could lead to legal consequences. The judges pointed out that the existing rules require the ECI to consider requests for changes based on the current electoral roll, not a draft one. The ECI’s counsel explained that the guidelines state that individuals who fail to submit the necessary forms risk having their names deleted. However, the court expressed concern that the process might inadvertently exclude eligible voters. The hearing will continue in future sessions.

How this report was made. Objective News wrote this report from 2 source articles, using AI-assisted synthesis under our methodology. It is our own text, not a copy of any single outlet. Read our methodology.

Responsible editor: Matej BašaSpotted an error? Report it

2 reports

The Indian Express logoThe Indian ExpressIndependentCenterFactual 85Objective 80
‘If citizens being removed, what is purpose of SIR?’ Bombay High Court asks Election Commission

The Bombay High Court in Goa questioned the purpose of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) process conducted by the Election Commission of India (ECI), highlighting concerns that citizens might be excluded from the electoral rolls despite the SIR's intent to ensure universal voter registration. The court heard a petition from Paresh Salgaoncar and five family members whose names were removed from the electoral rolls after their Form 8 applications for changing their address were rejected. The court emphasized that the ECI has a responsibility to ensure all citizens are included in the voter list and criticized the current system for creating a 'Catch-22' scenario for voters who are unable to update their information without facing legal risks. The court pointed out that under Rule 21 of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, the ECI must consider requests for address changes based on the existing voter roll rather than a draft roll, leaving voters with limited options for rectifying errors.

Bias read (Center): The article presents the Bombay High Court's questioning of the Election Commission's procedures regarding voter registration and the potential exclusion of citizens from the electoral rolls. It does not exhibit clear bias toward either side but highlights the legal and procedural challenges faced.

Why factuality (85): The article accurately reports the Bombay High Court’s questioning of the purpose of the SIR process when citizens are excluded from the voters' list. It provides details of the legal arguments presented by the court, including references to specific rules and the petitioner's case. The reporting al

Why objectivity (80): The article presents the court's concerns and legal reasoning in a neutral manner, focusing on the facts and legal arguments. However, there is a slight editorial tilt in phrases like 'Catch-22 situation,' which may imply a judgment on the fairness of the process rather than purely presenting the co

Times of India logoTimes of IndiaIndependentCenterFactual 75Objective 85
'If SIR excludes citizens from voters list, what is its purpose?': Bombay HC to EC

The Bombay High Court has raised concerns about the Election Commission's (EC) process of removing Indian citizens from electoral rolls during special revisions. The court emphasized the need to ensure that only genuine citizens remain on the voter lists and warned against the potential exclusion of eligible voters due to flawed procedures. The justices criticized the EC's guidelines and submission requirements as insufficient, suggesting they do not adequately protect voters' rights. The case will be addressed further in upcoming hearings.

Bias read (Center): The article presents a balanced account of the court's inquiry into the EC's procedures without overtly favoring either side. It reports on the legal scrutiny of the process without taking a clear ideological stance, focusing on procedural adequacy rather than partisan critique.

Why factuality (75): The article accurately reports the Bombay High Court questioning the Election Commission regarding the exclusion of Paresh Salgaonkar and his family from the electoral rolls. It includes direct quotes from the court and mentions relevant legal rules. However, some details like the exact nature of Fo

Why objectivity (85): The article maintains a largely neutral tone, presenting the court's questions and the Election Commission's responses without overt bias. The language is formal and objective, though it does highlight the court's concerns, which could be interpreted as slightly favoring the plaintiffs' perspective.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories