ON
← Back to feed
How a conspiracy theory embraced by Trump became part of mainstream Australian politics
Australia🏛️ PoliticsConservativeOverlooked by progressives12 days ago

How a conspiracy theory embraced by Trump became part of mainstream Australian politics

This opinion piece examines the growing influence of far-right immigration narratives in Australian politics, particularly those linked to the 'Great Replacement Theory', a conspiracy theory suggesting that Western societies are being infiltrated by immigrants to replace native populations. The article highlights how these ideas, once associated with fringe movements, are now gaining traction among mainstream political figures such as One Nation leader Pauline Hanson and former Liberal Party leader Tony Abbott. It notes the potential consequences of reducing migration levels, including labor shortages and economic challenges. The author critiques the narrative as dangerous and misleading, pointing out that the theory has been used to justify racially motivated violence against both Muslim and Jewish communities. The article references various sources, including reports on migration statistics and analyses of extremist ideologies.

Australia's political landscape has shifted dramatically in recent years, with far-right narratives increasingly shaping public discourse. At the heart of this transformation lies a conspiracy theory originally popularized by former U.S. President Donald Trump, which has found fertile ground in Australia's growing right-wing movement. As the country grapples with rising concerns over immigration, the influence of these ideas has moved beyond fringe circles and into mainstream political debate. The theory, known as the "great replacement," posits that demographic changes in the West, particularly the increasing presence of non-white populations, are the result of a coordinated effort by leftist and Jewish elites to replace white populations through controlled immigration policies. This belief has gained traction among certain segments of Australia's political class, especially within the Liberal Party and the far-right One Nation party. Both parties have expressed support for reducing immigration levels, with the Liberal Party aiming to lower annual intake to its lowest point since 2009. One Nation, led by Senator Pauline Hanson, has become a major force in Australian politics, currently leading federal polls. Its rhetoric aligns closely with the great replacement theory, framing immigration as a threat to national identity and cultural preservation. In 2025, One Nation senator Malcolm Roberts openly endorsed the idea of "remigration", the forced deportation of non-white immigrants and their descendants, as a potential solution to perceived demographic threats. Similarly, Pauline Hanson publicly supported the idea of mass deportations, stating, "I love it," when asked about a UK far-right party's similar proposal. This ideology has not gone unnoticed by other political figures. Tony Abbott, former Prime Minister and current leader of the Liberal Party, has echoed elements of the great replacement theory in his writings. In a statement, he suggested that "green-left, cultural Marxist governments" view mass migration from the "global south" not as a challenge, but as a deliberate strategy to reshape societies. His comments reflect a broader trend within conservative circles in Australia, where fears of cultural erosion and loss of national sovereignty are being amplified by such theories. The origins of the great replacement theory can be traced to the United States, where it emerged under Donald Trump's leadership. In 2025, the Trump administration established an Office of Remigration within the State Department, though details of its operations remain obscure. Reports suggest that this office was intended to facilitate large-scale repatriation of non-white immigrants, drawing parallels with the policies advocated by One Nation leaders. While the extent of U.S.-Australian collaboration on this issue remains unclear, the ideological overlap is undeniable. The consequences of this ideology have been dire. Since 2017, individuals influenced by the great replacement theory have carried out numerous racially motivated attacks, with Muslims and Jews often being the primary targets. The most infamous case occurred in 2019, when the Christchurch shooter, inspired by the theory, killed 51 Muslims in New Zealand. His manifesto explicitly referenced the great replacement narrative, highlighting its dangerous appeal to extremist thinking. As the political climate continues to evolve, the normalization of these ideas poses significant challenges for Australia's democratic institutions. With One Nation gaining momentum and the Liberal Party adopting more hardline stances on immigration, the risk of policy shifts that could lead to mass deportations or other restrictive measures grows. The implications extend beyond immigration policy, raising questions about the protection of minority rights and the integrity of Australia's multicultural framework. The path forward will depend on how these debates unfold in the coming months and whether the broader public remains vigilant against the spread of harmful ideologies.

Go to the primary sources (6)

The official sources this coverage is built on. Read them directly to bypass framing.

2 reports

The Age logoThe AgeIndependentConservativeFactual 0Objective 012 days ago
How a conspiracy theory embraced by Trump became part of mainstream Australian politics

This opinion piece examines the growing influence of far-right immigration narratives in Australian politics, particularly those linked to the 'Great Replacement Theory', a conspiracy theory suggesting that Western societies are being infiltrated by immigrants to replace native populations. The article highlights how these ideas, once associated with fringe movements, are now gaining traction among mainstream political figures such as One Nation leader Pauline Hanson and former Liberal Party leader Tony Abbott. It notes the potential consequences of reducing migration levels, including labor shortages and economic challenges. The author critiques the narrative as dangerous and misleading, pointing out that the theory has been used to justify racially motivated violence against both Muslim and Jewish communities. The article references various sources, including reports on migration statistics and analyses of extremist ideologies.

Bias read (Conservative): The article frames the 'Great Replacement Theory' as a legitimate concern while attributing blame to leftist and Jewish elites, using loaded language and emphasizing the dangers posed by this ideology. It presents the far-right perspective as a valid political movement rather than a fringe or racist

Why factuality (0): This article does not discuss the primary source document about Australia's migration statistics. Instead, it focuses on a completely different topic: the spread of a conspiracy theory in Australian politics. Therefore, it cannot be evaluated for factuality regarding the migration data. Its content

Why objectivity (0): The article uses emotionally charged language and presents a biased perspective on political ideology, focusing on a conspiracy theory. It lacks neutrality and presents a one-sided view of political trends, making it highly subjective.

The Sydney Morning Herald logoThe Sydney Morning HeraldIndependentConservativeFactual 0Objective 012 days ago
How a conspiracy theory embraced by Trump became part of mainstream Australian politics

This opinion piece discusses the growing influence of far-right immigration narratives in Australian politics, drawing parallels between these ideas and those promoted by former U.S. President Donald Trump. It highlights how the 'great replacement' theory, claiming a conspiracy by leftist and Jewish elites to replace white populations through immigration, is being adopted by Australian political figures such as Tony Abbott. The article critiques the theory as a dangerous ideology linked to racially motivated violence and suggests that the true threat lies within Australia itself, citing secret campaigns by religious groups supporting conservative politicians. The piece warns of potential societal impacts if such ideologies gain more traction.

Bias read (Conservative): The article frames the 'great replacement' theory as a legitimate concern, aligns with right-wing political figures like Tony Abbott, and presents the narrative as a credible threat to national identity. It emphasizes fears of immigrant influence and racial replacement, using terms like 'white-genoc

Why factuality (0): This article also does not reference or discuss the primary source document about Australia's migration statistics. It continues the discussion from Article 0, focusing on political ideology and conspiracy theories rather than migration data. Thus, it cannot be assessed for factuality related to the

Why objectivity (0): Similar to Article 0, this piece presents a biased and emotionally charged narrative about political movements and conspiracy theories. It fails to maintain objectivity and offers a one-sided interpretation of political developments.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories