'Heartless': Pro-Palestinian groups criticised for October 7 vigils
Pro-Palestinian organizations have faced criticism for organizing vigils commemorating the third anniversary of Hamas' attacks on Israel, which resulted in over 1,200 deaths. The vigils have drawn accusations of being 'heartless,' suggesting they may be seen as insensitive or inappropriate given the scale of loss. This controversy highlights ongoing tensions surrounding the commemoration of events related to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The criticism reflects broader societal debates about how such historical events should be remembered and discussed publicly.
New South Wales Premier Chris Minns has acknowledged he cannot prevent some of his Labor colleagues from attending pro-Palestinian vigils scheduled for October 7, despite condemning the events as “heartless.” The vigils, organized by two groups, Jews Against the Occupation 48 and Wollongong Friends of Palestine, are set to take place in Sydney and Wollongong. Minns criticized the timing of the demonstrations, arguing that holding them on the anniversary of the October 7 terror attack in Israel is provocative and inappropriate. Minns expressed frustration that some members of his government might still choose to participate in the vigils. While he has repeatedly urged Labor MPs to avoid the events, he admitted he cannot control their decisions. “I can certainly speak for my cabinet and I can certainly speak for my senior colleagues, but history has proven I can’t speak for all of them,” he said. Opposition to the vigils extends beyond Minns. Upper house Labor MP Anthony D’Adam, known for his support of the pro-Palestinian movement, stated he would not attend the events, calling them “unnecessary.” D’Adam emphasized that the violence on October 7 was a war crime and a violation of human rights, but argued that there was no need to make a political statement on that day. The vigils have drawn sharp criticism from Jewish organizations, including the Executive Council of Australian Jewry. Co-chief executive Alex Ryvchin described October 7 as a “solemn day” for Jewish and Israeli communities and urged organizers to choose another date for their protest. He warned that such events risk fostering extremism and antisemitism, particularly in light of the Bondi Beach massacre earlier this year. Minns reiterated that the vigils are legal but questioned the intent behind organizing them on the anniversary of the attack. He suggested the organizers seek attention and notoriety. “These organisers, in many cases, thrive on the notoriety and the attention they get,” he said. The controversy reflects broader tensions within the New South Wales government regarding the pro-Palestinian movement. Minns has faced internal resistance over his efforts to restrict protests against Israel’s military operations in Gaza, where the health ministry estimates around 74,000 Palestinians, mostly civilians, have died. Earlier this year, a failed attempt to ban the “March for Humanity” saw several Labor MPs participating in the demonstration, including high-profile figures like Penny Sharpe, the government’s leader in the upper house. Anke Klevjer, a member of Wollongong Friends of Palestine, defended the decision to hold the vigils on October 7. She argued that the date should not be sanitized to exclude Palestinian mourning. “We will not allow the martyrdom of the Palestinian people to be scrubbed from this historical record of October 7,” she said. Michelle Berkon, a spokesperson for Jews Against the Occupation 48, countered that it is heartless to suggest only certain victims deserve remembrance. She insisted on the right to mourn Palestinian lives and denied claims that the pro-Palestinian movement promotes extremism. Berkon cited Australia’s intelligence agency, ASIO, noting that the most concerning extremist views in the country stem from far-right and white supremacist groups. NSW Opposition Leader Kellie Sloane condemned the vigils as “sickening” and “reprehensible,” though she acknowledged the distress felt by those concerned about conditions in Gaza. She called for unity and respectful dialogue instead of divisive protests. The vigils are set to proceed as planned, highlighting the deep divisions over how to commemorate the events of October 7 and the ongoing conflict in the Middle East.
Go to the primary sources (1)
The official sources this coverage is built on. Read them directly to bypass framing.
Premier Chris Minns and opposition leader Kellie Sloane have both criticized pro-Palestine vigils scheduled for October 7, commemorating the Palestinian attacks on Israel. However, Premier Minns has stated that these vigils cannot be blocked, indicating a lack of government intervention. The article highlights the differing stances between the governing and opposition leaders regarding the event, which reflects broader political tensions around the issue.
Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the vigils as 'heartless' and emphasizes the inability of the government to stop them, suggesting a critique of the pro-Palestine stance while highlighting the Premier’s reluctance to intervene. This framing leans toward supporting the vigils and questioning their morality, aligns
Why factuality (98): This article accurately reports the situation, citing the same groups, individuals, and statements as the first article. It includes direct quotes from Kellie Sloane and Anthony D’Adam, and correctly conveys that Minns cannot prevent attendance by Labor MPs. All information matches the cross-source
Why objectivity (75): The article maintains a relatively neutral tone but still uses phrases like 'controversial', 'sickening', and 'provocative' to describe the vigils, which may subtly influence reader perception. However, it presents multiple viewpoints and avoids overtly taking sides.
Premier Chris Minns and opposition leader Kellie Sloane have criticized pro-Palestine vigils scheduled for October 7, describing them as 'heartless.' However, Minns has acknowledged that these vigils cannot be legally prevented despite his disapproval.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both the criticism of the vigils by Premier Chris Minns and opposition leader Kellie Sloane, without favoring one side over the other. It does not use biased language or selectively present information to support a particular viewpoint.
Why factuality (98): This article mirrors the content of article 1, presenting the same facts, quotes, and context regarding the vigils and political responses. It aligns closely with the cross-source consensus and provides no conflicting or inaccurate information.
Why objectivity (75): Like article 1, this article uses strong language to describe the vigils, such as 'sickening' and 'provocative', but it remains largely neutral in tone and presents opposing views without overt bias. It does not take a clear stance beyond reporting the controversy.
Pro-Palestinian organizations have faced criticism for organizing vigils commemorating the third anniversary of Hamas' attacks on Israel, which resulted in over 1,200 deaths. The vigils have drawn accusations of being 'heartless,' suggesting they may be seen as insensitive or inappropriate given the scale of loss. This controversy highlights ongoing tensions surrounding the commemoration of events related to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The criticism reflects broader societal debates about how such historical events should be remembered and discussed publicly.
Bias read (Center): The article presents a balanced view by noting that pro-Palestinian groups are being criticized for their vigils but does not take a stance on whether the criticism is justified. It reports the event neutrally without apparent bias toward either side of the debate.
Why factuality (95): The article provides specific details about the vigils, including the names of the organising groups, the dates, and quotes from officials like Chris Minns and Michelle Berkon. It references the UN Human Rights Council’s findings and mentions the Israeli government’s rejection of the genocide claim.
Why objectivity (70): The article uses emotionally charged terms such as 'heartless', 'in poor taste', and 'genocide' without providing counterpoints or balancing perspectives. While it includes quotes from both critics and organisers, the overall tone leans toward condemning the vigils, which introduces a degree of bias
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.