The Greatest Is a Biographical Drama That Understands Why Muhammad Ali Became a Legend
This review evaluates Prime Video's new biographical drama 'The Greatest,' which chronicles the early life of boxer Muhammad Ali, formerly known as Cassius Clay. The series stars Jaalen Best as the young athlete and explores his transition from a promising Olympic gold medalist to a global icon, highlighting his spiritual journey and changing identity. While acknowledging potential risks of hagiography due to the involvement of Ali's widow and actor Michael B. Jordan as executive producers, the reviewer praises creator Ben Watkins for addressing difficult aspects of Ali's life rather than shying away from them. The narrative contrasts the portrayal with previous films like 'Ali' and 'One Night in Miami,' noting that Best's depiction emphasizes the rawness of Ali's youth and self-possession. Key plot points include Ali's return to his segregated hometown of Louisville, Kentucky, and his complex family dynamics with his supportive mother and struggling father.
Prime Video released The Greatest, an eight-part biographical drama chronicling the meteoric rise of Muhammad Ali, on Wednesday. The series, created and partially directed by Ben Watkins, traces the trajectory of the boxer from his Olympic victory in Rome in 1960 to his capture of the world heavyweight title in Miami in 1964. The narrative concludes with Ali defeating Sonny Liston and publicly unveiling his new name, a moment that marked a definitive shift in his public identity. Subsequent seasons are anticipated to address later chapters of his life, including his refusal to serve in the Vietnam War, his activism, and major bouts such as the Thrilla in Manila and the Rumble in the Jungle. Jaalen Best portrays the young Cassius Clay, a role that critics describe as a near-perfect physical and spiritual match. Before viewing the premiere, some observers suspected artificial intelligence had enhanced Best’s resemblance to the legend, but he possesses a natural likeness that requires no digital alteration. Best stated he spent years studying Ali and training in the ring to embody the athlete. Lonnie Ali, the late boxer’s widow and an executive producer on the project, endorsed the casting, asserting that Ali himself would have approved of the selection. She also praised Best’s qualifications, noting his deep immersion in the role. Critics noted that while Best captures the ego, impatience, and self-importance of the young champion, he also conveys underlying softness, seriousness, and moments of doubt. At twenty-two years old during the timeframe depicted, Ali was still forming his adult persona, a complexity the performance attempts to navigate. The production team included Michael B. Jordan and rapper Jay-Z, the latter through his label Roc Nation. The series faces a unique structural challenge because its protagonist is widely regarded as the greatest boxer of all time, eliminating the traditional underdog narrative common in sports dramas. Instead of a scrappy climber fighting against insurmountable odds, the story depicts a world-class talent securing his position at the top of the hierarchy early and with minimal adversity. Despite this lack of conventional conflict, the show maintains engagement through visual richness and detailed period accuracy. Scenes feature mint-condition automobiles, historically accurate zip-up polo shirts, pastel rotary-dial telephones, and vintage issues of Jet magazine. Drone footage captured on location at the Colosseum in Italy adds to the cinematic scope, leveraging the financial resources available to streaming platforms. Drama emerges primarily from the figures surrounding Ali rather than from his athletic dominance alone. His early professional victories were so one-sided that they appear largely in montage form, compressing nineteen fights into brief segments. Significant tension arises from the relationship between Cassius Clay Jr. and his father, Cassius "Cash" Clay Sr., portrayed by Omari Hardwick. Hardwick depicts the elder Clay as a frustrated sign painter who believed he was denied proper artistic training. This resentment manifests in a household dynamic described as a one-man authoritarian regime, where the father alternates between scolding, bullying, and cajoling his family. Hardwick portrays a man aware of his wrongdoing yet unable to cease it. In one poignant scene, the father expresses pride in his son, a statement that appears to cause him physical distress due to the difficulty of acknowledging his child's superiority. Other key cast members include Giovanni Ribisi as trainer Angelo Dundee, who advises the family that Ali is an artist rather than a mere fighter, comparing him to Michelangelo. Reno Wilson plays cornerman Drew Bundini Brown, while Michael Ealy portrays Malcolm X. Amin Joseph delivers a nuanced performance as Sonny Liston, avoiding the reduction of the opponent to a simple antagonist. The series treats Liston’s storyline with equal weight to Ali’s, shifting focus between the two men as they prepare for their bout. Although the production features a relatively modest budget compared to major studio films, it is well-appointed with period-appropriate dress, furnishings, and signage. The tone remains generally kind but critical, balancing the celebration of Ali’s charisma with an examination of the interpersonal frictions that defined his early career. The series offers a comprehensive look at the transformation from Cassius Clay to Muhammad Ali before the later controversies of his life.
3 reports
TIMEIndependentCenterFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 85
This review evaluates Prime Video's new biographical drama 'The Greatest,' which chronicles the early life of boxer Muhammad Ali, formerly known as Cassius Clay. The series stars Jaalen Best as the young athlete and explores his transition from a promising Olympic gold medalist to a global icon, highlighting his spiritual journey and changing identity. While acknowledging potential risks of hagiography due to the involvement of Ali's widow and actor Michael B. Jordan as executive producers, the reviewer praises creator Ben Watkins for addressing difficult aspects of Ali's life rather than shying away from them. The narrative contrasts the portrayal with previous films like 'Ali' and 'One Night in Miami,' noting that Best's depiction emphasizes the rawness of Ali's youth and self-possession. Key plot points include Ali's return to his segregated hometown of Louisville, Kentucky, and his complex family dynamics with his supportive mother and struggling father.
Bias read (Center): The article maintains a balanced critical tone, acknowledging potential biases in production while praising the nuanced handling of historical and social contexts without adopting a partisan stance.
Why factuality: no official source document/info detected
Why objectivity (85): Balanced and analytical. While positive ('unusually insightful'), it acknowledges potential biases (hagiography risk due to widow's involvement) before refuting them based on the content. Maintains a professional critical distance without excessive praise or dismissal.
Los Angeles TimesIndependent🔒CenterFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 75
This review evaluates the Prime Video series 'The Greatest,' which chronicles the early career of boxer Muhammad Ali from his Olympic victory in 1960 to his 1964 heavyweight championship win against Sonny Liston. The author notes that while they typically avoid sports and biopics, this series succeeds due to its manageable eight-episode structure covering a specific historical period. The review highlights the performance of Jaalen Best as Cassius Clay, praising his ability to capture both the ego and vulnerability of the young athlete. It mentions that the show was created by Ben Watkins and produced with input from Ali's widow, Lonnie Ali. The piece suggests that stopping the narrative at the 1964 title fight provides a strong artistic conclusion before moving on to later controversies.
Bias read (Center): The review focuses primarily on cinematic quality and acting performances rather than political ideology, offering a balanced assessment of the biographical drama without taking a stance on the underlying social issues depicted.
Why factuality: no official source document/info detected
Why objectivity (75): Personal and conversational tone. Opens with the author's lack of interest in boxing/biopics, which adds a layer of personal bias but frames the review as a discovery piece. Less emotionally charged than Article 0, but still clearly favorable ('very good') and uses informal language ('sweet science'
SlateIndependentCenterFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 60
This article reviews 'The Greatest,' a new eight-episode Prime Video biographical drama series about Muhammad Ali. The piece highlights that the show focuses on Ali's rapid rise to fame rather than typical underdog narratives, noting that this premise poses a unique challenge for maintaining dramatic tension. It praises the production values, describing the visuals as sumptuous with detailed period props and high-quality cinematography. The review emphasizes the exceptional performance of newcomer Jaalen Best, whose physical resemblance to Ali is described as eerie and convincing, noting that his casting was endorsed by Ali's widow, Lonnie. The article suggests that while the story lacks traditional conflict, the craftsmanship and star power make the series consistently compelling.
Bias read (Center): The article treats the subject as entertainment and sports history, using neutral descriptive language and focusing on artistic merit rather than political implications.
Why factuality: no official source document/info detected
Why objectivity (60): Highly subjective and promotional in tone. Uses strong positive adjectives like 'surprisingly compelling,' 'charmed rise,' and 'visually sumptuous.' Frames the narrative as a 'world-historical talent finding his deserved place,' which injects the reviewer's personal admiration rather than maintainin
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.