Beppe Grillo has once again ignited controversy within the Five Star Movement (M5S), with his latest public remarks suggesting lingering resentment toward the party he founded. The comments, posted on his personal blog, echo themes reminiscent of earlier tensions within the movement, raising questions about whether this is merely a continuation of old grievances or a potential catalyst for new political developments. Grillo’s recent statement, “I rivoluzionari hanno scoperto il palazzo”, translates to “The revolutionaries have discovered the palace”, suggests a belief that the M5S has been co-opted by establishment forces, despite its origins as a radical anti-establishment force. This sentiment comes amid ongoing internal divisions within the M5S, which has evolved significantly since its founding in 2009. Initially a grassroots movement led by Grillo and Gianroberto Casaleggio, the party grew into a major political force, known for its anti-corruption stance and direct engagement with citizens through online platforms. However, after Casaleggio's death in 2020, the party began shifting toward more institutionalized politics, leading to a split between Grillo and current leader Giuseppe Conte. This rift deepened during the formation of the Draghi government in 2021, when Grillo publicly endorsed the coalition, calling Draghi a “grillino,” or a member of the Five Star Movement, despite their ideological differences. Grillo’s relationship with Conte has further complicated matters. After serving briefly as Prime Minister in 2018, Grillo was sidelined following the 2022 elections, when the M5S lost ground to other parties. His son, Ciro, became embroiled in legal troubles, facing charges of rape alongside three friends, with convictions pending. These personal and legal challenges have contributed to a growing sense of alienation within the party, particularly among older members who feel their influence waning. In November 2024, during an assembly at EUR, members of the M5S voted to abolish the role of the party’s former president, Beppe Grillo, and to reassess alliances. This decision marked a turning point, effectively diminishing Grillo’s authority within the movement. Despite attempts to maintain a facade of unity, tensions remained visible, with some members openly criticizing the direction the party had taken under Conte. Recent posts from Grillo’s blog suggest that these tensions have not fully subsided. He continues to accuse the current leadership of betraying the movement’s original ideals, claiming that while the M5S sought to change the political system, the system has instead changed them. Such statements have drawn mixed reactions from within the party, with some supporters viewing them as justified critiques, while others see them as politically motivated provocations. Analysts suggest that Grillo’s renewed criticism could serve multiple purposes. It might be an attempt to regain relevance ahead of upcoming elections, or it could signal support for potential candidates who were previously marginalized within the movement. Some observers speculate that Grillo may be positioning himself to play a role in future political shifts, potentially aiding figures who were once considered “traitors” or outsiders to the party. Historically, Grillo has targeted prominent political rivals such as Silvio Berlusconi and Matteo Renzi, both of whom have faced accusations of undermining the very principles they helped shape. While Renzi is often criticized for dismantling movements he once supported, Grillo faces a different challenge, he is the architect of the movement he now claims has turned against him. This self-inflicted contradiction adds complexity to his current criticisms, making it difficult to assess whether they stem from genuine frustration or strategic maneuvering. As the situation unfolds, the M5S will likely continue to grapple with internal dynamics shaped by past conflicts and evolving political realities. Whether Grillo’s latest interventions mark a return to prominence or simply another chapter in the party’s turbulent history remains uncertain. What is clear, however, is that the movement is still navigating the legacy of its founder, even as it seeks to redefine itself in a changing political landscape.
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.
Become a Supporter
Italy
