A coalition advocating for sustainable transportation policy has expressed strong criticism towards a proposed garage building near Krvavec, located on the slopes of Planina Jezerca. The project, which includes a three-level basement structure with parking space for approximately 700 vehicles, has been deemed unsound and inconsistent with Alpine conventions by the group. According to a preliminary spatial plan released by the urbanist bureau, the building would be the highest such structure in Slovenia, situated at an elevation of over 1,400 meters above sea level. The coalition argues that there is no evidence of a comprehensive study assessing actual needs, traffic impacts, or alternative solutions aimed at reducing reliance on private vehicles in the area. This stance was echoed by Katarina Žemlja of Cipra Slovenia, which coordinates the coalition. She pointed out that while other local communities across the Alps implement measures to protect nature and reduce traffic in sensitive mountainous regions, the community of Jezerca and the Municipality of Cerklje na Gorenjskem are planning a garage building instead. The coalition’s concerns extend beyond environmental impact. They claim that the rationale for constructing the garage is not justified, particularly given its projected capacity, exceeding that of the parking facility at Congress Square in Ljubljana. Furthermore, they argue that the project fails to align with the municipality's own mobility strategy, which aims to increase public transport usage through new routes to Krvavec and connections to nearby towns. The municipal sustainability development strategy from 2021–2030 also emphasizes reducing dependence on personal cars, promoting sustainable tourism, and preserving nature as key priorities. Despite these strategic goals, the coalition claims that the detailed spatial plan submitted by the municipality does not reflect these objectives. Instead, it suggests increasing parking capacity as the primary solution for access to Krvavec, rather than implementing a holistic approach to mobility management. Additionally, the proposed garage construction appears to conflict with protocols under the Alpine Convention, which requires assessments of the significance of interventions, their environmental impacts, and verification of sustainable alternatives before expanding parking spaces for private vehicles. Both the manager of the ski resort RTC Krvavec and the Slovenian Mountain Association have raised concerns about the potential burden on high-altitude areas caused by the construction. The coalition has also criticized the Ministry of Environment and the Slovenian Environmental Protection Institute for relying on an environmental report from 2009, despite increased visitation and traffic since then. These institutions have not required a reassessment of the impact on protected areas, according to the coalition. In response, the coalition has recommended halting the current process for preparing the spatial plan until independent expert studies are conducted on traffic feasibility, environmental effects, water resources, and a thorough evaluation of sustainable alternatives such as public transport, car-sharing systems, and visitor management models used successfully in neighboring Italy. The coalition has also submitted feedback during the public disclosure phase of the spatial plan to the municipality of Cerklje na Gorenjskem.
3 reports
Gorenjski glasIndependentProgressiveFactual 95Objective 852 days agoThe article discusses criticism from the Coalition for Sustainable Mobility Policy regarding a proposed garage building project on Planina Jezerca under Krvavec. The project, which would accommodate around 700 vehicles, has been called 'unreasonable', 'overdimensioned', and inconsistent with the Alpine Convention. Critics argue that there is no comprehensive study of actual needs, traffic impacts, or alternative solutions that could reduce reliance on private vehicles. They point out that the local community and municipality of Cerklje na Gorenjskem have set goals to increase public transportation usage and promote sustainable tourism, yet the project ignores these objectives by focusing solely on expanding parking capacity. The coalition also highlights that the construction does not align with environmental protocols of the Alpine Convention, which require assessments of environmental impact and consideration of sustainable alternatives. Both the manager of the ski resort RTC Krvavec and the Slovenian Alpine Association have raised concerns about the burden on high-altitude areas, while the coalition criticizes the Ministry of Environment and the Nature Protection Institute for a
Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the proposed garage building as environmentally harmful and inconsistent with regional sustainability goals, emphasizing the need for ecological responsibility and public transportation over private vehicle use. It critiques the lack of environmental assessment and alignment with崤
Why factuality (95): The article provides specific details about the proposed garage house, including three basement levels and a ground-level parking area, citing the Urban Planning Office as the source. It also references the size of the structure compared to the Kongresni trg parking garage in Ljubljana and mentions
Why objectivity (85): The article presents the concerns raised by the coalition in a critical tone but does not explicitly take sides beyond reporting their objections. However, it uses phrases like 'nesmotrn' (unreasonable) and 'predimenzioniran' (overdimensioned) which may imply judgment rather than neutrality. The ove
DnevnikIndependent🔒CenterFactual 85Objective 752 days agoA proposed multi-level parking structure on Planina Jezerca below Mount Krvavec has sparked debate between the Municipality of Cerklje na Gorenjskem and environmental advocates. The municipality presents the project as necessary to manage chaotic parking and protect water sources, while the Coalition for Sustainable Transport Policy criticizes the lack of professional justification and claims the project contradicts principles of sustainable mobility. The planned facility would provide over 700 parking spaces at approximately 1,400 meters above sea level, addressing increasing traffic pressures but drawing sharp criticism over potential impacts on nature, water resources, and future development of the Alpine area. Mayor Franc Čebulj argues that the current unregulated parking poses serious risks, especially due to proximity to a critical water source serving around 50,000 people. He believes the garage would allow traffic control and reduce pollution risks, though critics argue the focus should be on promoting public transport and other forms of sustainable mobility.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both perspectives—support from the local municipality emphasizing infrastructure needs and environmental protection, and opposition from sustainability advocates highlighting ecological concerns. It does not favor one side through loaded language, one-sided sourcing, or omission
Why factuality (85): The article accurately reports the controversy around the planned multi-story garage building on Planina Jezerca under Krvavec, mentioning both the municipality's stance and the coalition's concerns. It references the visualizations by the Coalition for Sustainable Mobility Policy and quotes officia
Why objectivity (75): The article presents both sides of the argument but leans slightly towards the municipality's perspective by quoting the mayor and emphasizing the 'chaotic parking' issue. While it includes criticism from the coalition, the tone remains somewhat supportive of the local government's position.
Slovenske noviceIndependentProgressive1 hr. agoThe Pašna Skupnost Jezerca and the Municipality of Cerklje na Gorenjskem plan to build a garage building with over 700 parking spaces on the Krvavec mountain. The Coalition for Sustainable Mobility Policy (KTPP) opposes this project, arguing it conflicts with the Alpine Convention and the municipality’s own traffic strategy goals, which aim to reduce car dependency and increase public transport. The proposed development has been halted by the ski resort manager and the mountaineering association due to environmental concerns. The mayor, Franc Čebulj, explains the project aims to protect water resources and includes the renovation of sewage systems. KTPP criticizes the lack of comprehensive studies on demand, traffic impacts, and sustainable alternatives, stating the capacity would exceed similar structures in Slovenia and could become the highest such building at 1,400 meters above sea level. They call for halting the planning process until independent expert assessments are completed.
Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the opposition to the garage construction as a conflict between local interests and broader environmental and sustainability goals. It highlights the coalition's concern about ecological impact and promotes the idea that the project contradicts the municipality's stated objectives
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter
Slovenia
