The Italian political landscape has been shaken by a heated debate over the legal definition of "feminicide," sparked by statements made by Roberto Vannacci, the leader of the newly formed party Futuro Nazionale (FN). During the second day of FN's constituent assembly in Rome, Vannacci declared that "feminicide does not exist—it is just another murder." His remarks have ignited fierce criticism from various political figures, legal experts, and women’s rights advocates, who argue that his stance undermines efforts to address the systemic issue of violence against women.
Vannacci’s comments were delivered during a packed press conference following the assembly, where he outlined his party’s platform, which includes policies on migration, military discipline, and economic reform. When questioned about the concept of feminicide—a term used to describe murders of women motivated by their gender—Vannacci rejected its validity. He argued that "murder is murder, regardless of the victim's sex, skin color, or religion," emphasizing what he called "true equality." This position was reinforced when he stated outright, "Feminicide does not exist."
His rejection of the term has drawn sharp responses from several quarters. Eugenia Roccella, Italy’s Minister for Family, Fertility, and Equal Opportunities, criticized Vannacci for failing to grasp the distinction between genders. She emphasized that the term "feminicide" is used because the motive behind such crimes is specifically tied to the victim being a woman. Roccella pointed out that under current legislation, the punishment for killing a woman within certain relational contexts—such as stable cohabitation, marriage, or civil union—is severe, including life imprisonment. The minister stressed that this legal framework recognizes the unique nature of these crimes and the need to protect women from targeted violence.
Other critics, including politicians from the Democratic Party (PD), Avanguardia Nazionale (Avs), and Italia Viva, condemned Vannacci’s remarks as dangerous and dismissive of the reality faced by many women in Italy. They described his stance as "patriarchal denialism," arguing that it ignores the documented patterns of male violence against women. These critics highlighted that the phenomenon of feminicide is well-documented by institutions, the judiciary, and international organizations, and that recognizing it is crucial for addressing the underlying dynamics of possession, control, and domination that often lead to such crimes.
Giulia Bongiorno, a senator from the League and rapporteur on the bill concerning sexual violence, also responded strongly. She noted that the issue is not whether a woman’s death weighs more than a man’s, but rather the severity of the motivation behind the act—specifically, hatred or disdain for women, viewing them as inferior beings. Bongiorno warned that Vannacci’s views might reflect a longing for outdated laws that once allowed leniency in cases of honor-based killings, a practice abolished in 1981.
Beyond the political sphere, public reaction has been mixed. While some supporters of FN applaud Vannacci for challenging what they see as ideological constructs around gender equality, others view his comments as deeply offensive and potentially harmful. Critics argue that his rejection of the term "feminicide" could hinder progress in creating effective legal protections and support systems for victims of gender-based violence.
Vannacci’s broader political agenda, which includes advocating for stricter immigration controls, promoting meritocracy over quotas, and rejecting what he calls "subservience" to European Union regulations, has further polarized opinions. His party, which claims to have 100,000 members, has positioned itself as an alternative to mainstream parties, promising to bring about change through strong leadership and a focus on national interests.
Despite the controversy surrounding his remarks on feminicide, Vannacci has remained steadfast in his position. He has even challenged Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni to hold early elections, asserting that Futuro Nazionale is ready to take on government responsibilities immediately. This bold move underscores the growing influence of FN and the potential impact it could have on Italy’s political future.
As the debate continues, the implications of Vannacci’s stance remain significant. Whether his views will gain traction among the public or face continued opposition from legal and advocacy groups remains to be seen. However, one thing is clear: the discussion over the meaning and significance of "feminicide" has become a central point of contention in Italy’s ongoing struggle to address gender-based violence and promote true equality.
6 reports
OpenIndependentConservativeFactual 95Objective 5524 days agoRoberto Vannacci, leader of the Italian political group Futuro Nazionale, denied the existence of 'femicide' during an event in Rome, stating that it is simply another type of murder. He emphasized gender equality by arguing that men and women are equal and should be subject to the same rules, rejecting the idea of special protections based on sex. Vannacci also challenged Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, stating that his party is ready for early elections at any time.
Bias read (Conservative): The article presents Vannacci's explicit denial of the concept of femmicide, which is a highly contested social issue. His framing rejects the notion of gender-specific violence and frames it as a matter of equality under universal rules, aligning with conservative perspectives that oppose gendered-
Why these scores (Factual 95 · Objective 55): Highly factual, reporting directly on Roccella’s response to Vannacci without embellishment. However, the tone is clearly adversarial, presenting her critique as a rebuttal to Vannacci’s position, which shows a lack of balance and objectivity.
OpenIndependentProgressiveFactual 92Objective 5820 days ago Femicide, even Roccella loses patience with Vannacci: He does not have a clear sexual difference between men and womenThe Italian minister for Family, Fertility, and Equal Opportunities, Eugenia Roccella, criticized europarlamentary Roberto Vannacci for his comments on the concept of 'feminicide.' Roccella emphasized that the term refers specifically to the killing of a woman due to her gender, distinguishing it from other forms of homicide. She argued that Vannacci lacks clarity on the sexual difference between men and women and suggested that Vannacci misunderstood the legal definition of feminicide.
Bias read (Progressive): The article presents the minister's criticism of Vannacci using strong language ('non ha chiara la differenza sessuale') and frames the discussion around the legal and social significance of 'feminicide,' which aligns with progressive perspectives on gender-based violence. The framing emphasizes the
Why these scores (Factual 92 · Objective 58): Accurate in reporting the backlash against Vannacci from various political figures, including D’Elia and Di Biase. While it provides factual information, the language used ('bufera politica', 'negazionismo patriarcale') suggests a clear ideological stance, reducing objectivity.
Il Fatto QuotidianoIndependentConservativeFactual 90Objective 7524 days agoRoberto Vannacci, leader of Futuro nazionale, stated during an assembly that 'femicide does not exist' and that there is no need for a specific crime related to it, arguing that men and women are equal and should be subject to the same rules regardless of gender, race, or religion. His comments have sparked political backlash, with opposition figures accusing him of 'patriarchal negationism.' Vannacci also expressed opposition to so-called 'pink quotas' and plans to propose an amendment to abolish them in electoral law.
Bias read (Conservative): The article presents Vannacci’s controversial remarks about the non-existence of femicide and his opposition to gender equality measures like 'pink quotas,' which are framed as extreme right-wing positions. The framing emphasizes the political backlash against these views, highlighting their radical
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 75): The article presents Vannacci’s claim that femminicidio does not exist as a factual statement and includes responses from political opponents. While it cites opposing viewpoints, it uses emotionally charged terms like ‘negazionismo patriarcale,’ which may affect neutrality.
Il Sole 24 OreParty-aligned🔒ConservativeFactual 90Objective 6524 days agoRoberto Vannacci, leader of Futuro Nazionale, stated during his party's constituent assembly that 'feminicide' does not exist and that it is unnecessary to have a specific law protecting women. He argued that all murders are equal regardless of gender, race, or religion, emphasizing equality under the same rules. Vannacci previously criticized the concept of feminicide as a 'bulwark of the right' that has been 'broken.' He also questioned the logic of implementing gender quotas in certain professions but not others.
Bias read (Conservative): The article presents Vannacci's argument against the existence of 'feminicide' as a specific crime, which frames the issue through a lens that downplays gender-specific violence. The framing uses terms like 'bulwark of the right' and questions the necessity of gender-based protections, aligning with
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 65): The article provides a direct quote from Vannacci and contextualizes his remarks within the political framework of his party. It maintains factual consistency with other sources but still leans slightly toward a partisan tone by highlighting his controversial positions without balancing them with op
ANSAIndependentConservativeFactual 88Objective 6224 days agoRoberto Vannacci, leader of the newly formed political party Futuro Nazionale, has stated that the crime of 'femicide' does not exist and that it is simply an ordinary murder. He argues that crimes should not be judged based on the gender, race, or religion of the victim or perpetrator, calling this true equality. Vannacci also expressed opposition to gender-related policies and affirmative action, which aligns with his broader political stance.
Bias read (Conservative): The article presents Vannacci's explicit rejection of the concept of 'feminicide,' framing it as a non-existent category and equating it to any other murder. This framing dismisses the specific societal and legal context surrounding violence against women, which is typically emphasized in feminist,左
Why these scores (Factual 88 · Objective 62): This article repeats Vannacci’s main arguments and includes quotes from him, maintaining factual alignment with other reports. However, it frames his statements as a challenge to established norms, which introduces some bias despite the factual content being accurate.
ANSAIndependentCenterFactual 85Objective 6024 days ago Vannacci without brakes: 'The femicide does not exist, a murder like any other'Roberto Vannacci, leader of the newly formed political party Futuro Nazionale, has made controversial statements denying the existence of 'femicide,' calling it an 'absurdity' and asserting that murder should not be categorized based on the victim's gender. He argues that true equality means treating all crimes equally regardless of the victim's sex, race, or religion. The article details his political rise and his stance against gender quotas and what he describes as 'gender ideology.'
Bias read (Center): The article reports on political statements without taking a position or showing clear bias in framing. It presents Vannacci's views directly but does not editorialize or favor one side over another.
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 60): Factual accuracy is high as it accurately reports Vannacci’s statements about the femminicidio not existing and his stance on gender issues. However, the article presents these views in a highly charged and emotionally charged manner, using terms like 'orgogliosamente controcorrente' and 'scaglia la
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter
Italy
