ON
← Back to feed
Extreme climber Huber: "We're glad we can ski, but it has to be enough now".
Germany🏛️ PoliticsProgressiveyesterday

Extreme climber Huber: "We're glad we can ski, but it has to be enough now".

Alexander Huber, ein bekannter Extremkletterer, unterstützt nun die Umweltschutzorganisation Mountain Wilderness als Garant. Er übernimmt diese Rolle nachdem Richard Goedeke, einer der Gründer der Organisation, aufgrund von Altersgründen seine Position beendet hat. Huber kritisiert aktuelle Pläne zur Modernisierung der Scheidtobelbahn in Oberstdorf, insbesondere die geplante Verlegung der Tal- und Bergstation sowie die Ausweitung der Talstation um das Fünffache und der Bergstation um das Zehnfache. Diese Maßnahmen würden laut Huber den Naturraum schädigen, insbesondere das Lebensraumgebiet der Birkhühner, das in der Region besonders wichtig ist. Er warnt vor der Auswirkung des „Dritten Modernisierungsgesetzes“ der bayerischen Regierung, das ab 2023 Seilbahnprojekte bis zu 1,5 km Länge von einer Umweltverträglichkeitsprüfung befreit. Huber betont, dass der Naturschutz durch dieses Gesetz nicht gewährleistet werde.

Alexander Huber, a renowned extreme climber known for his free solo climbs and speed records, has shifted focus from conquering peaks to protecting the last remnants of wilderness in Germany’s Alps. In recent months, he has taken on the role of a “guarantor” for the environmental organization Mountain Wilderness, which campaigns to preserve untouched natural areas in the region. The move comes after one of the group's founders, Richard Goedeke, stepped down due to age-related reasons. Huber, who has been active in nature conservation for decades, accepted the position, citing long-standing ties with Goedeke and shared values. Huber is currently engaged in efforts to oppose a proposed modernization of the Scheidtobelbahn cable car system in Oberstdorf, Bavaria. The project involves replacing the existing infrastructure, but critics argue that the plan includes changes to the cable car route and ski lift layout, along with the construction of a large snowmaking reservoir. These alterations threaten the habitat of the capercaillie, a rare bird species whose largest population in Germany resides in the area. The Scheidtobel valley is part of the Natura 2000 network, a European Union initiative designed to protect biodiversity and ecosystems. Any degradation of this environment would violate EU regulations. The controversy centers around a new law passed by the Bavarian state government last year, the Third Modernization Act, which exempts certain small-scale cable car projects, those under 1.5 kilometers in length, from undergoing environmental impact assessments. The Scheidtobelbahn, measuring 1.45 kilometers, falls within this exemption. This legal loophole allows the project to proceed without thorough ecological scrutiny, despite concerns raised by environmental groups. Huber criticized the legislation, stating that it was enacted without fully considering its consequences for nature protection. He had previously discussed these concerns with Environment Minister Thorsten Glauber of the Free Voters party, who assured him that natural protections would remain intact. However, the current situation suggests otherwise. Huber emphasized that while infrastructure such as huts, trails, and lifts have made the Alps more accessible, there should be limits to human encroachment. He acknowledged the benefits of skiing and other recreational activities but argued that the balance must shift toward preserving the remaining pristine landscapes. His stance reflects a broader philosophy that prioritizes sustainability over expansion. This perspective aligns with past efforts to prevent rock climbing restrictions in the 1990s, when he worked alongside the Bavarian Society for Bird and Nature Conservation (LBV) to ensure climbing remained possible while minimizing harm to wildlife habitats. Mountain Wilderness, the organization Huber now represents, has organized protests and public awareness campaigns against the Scheidtobelbahn project. Their arguments highlight the need for responsible tourism and infrastructure planning that respects ecological boundaries. They advocate for maintaining the status quo of the cable car system rather than expanding it in ways that could irreversibly damage the local ecosystem. The group has called on authorities to reconsider the project’s scope and ensure compliance with EU environmental standards. Environmentalists and outdoor enthusiasts continue to monitor developments in Oberstdorf, hoping for a resolution that balances economic interests with ecological preservation. The debate over the Scheidtobelbahn underscores larger questions about how to manage mountain regions sustainably. As discussions progress, the outcome will likely influence future policies regarding infrastructure in protected natural areas across Germany.

1 reports

Frankfurter Allgemeine (FAZ) logoFrankfurter Allgemeine (FAZ)Independent🔒ProgressiveFactual 85Objective 75yesterday
Extreme climber Huber: "We're glad we can ski, but it has to be enough now".

Alexander Huber, ein bekannter Extremkletterer, unterstützt nun die Umweltschutzorganisation Mountain Wilderness als Garant. Er übernimmt diese Rolle nachdem Richard Goedeke, einer der Gründer der Organisation, aufgrund von Altersgründen seine Position beendet hat. Huber kritisiert aktuelle Pläne zur Modernisierung der Scheidtobelbahn in Oberstdorf, insbesondere die geplante Verlegung der Tal- und Bergstation sowie die Ausweitung der Talstation um das Fünffache und der Bergstation um das Zehnfache. Diese Maßnahmen würden laut Huber den Naturraum schädigen, insbesondere das Lebensraumgebiet der Birkhühner, das in der Region besonders wichtig ist. Er warnt vor der Auswirkung des „Dritten Modernisierungsgesetzes“ der bayerischen Regierung, das ab 2023 Seilbahnprojekte bis zu 1,5 km Länge von einer Umweltverträglichkeitsprüfung befreit. Huber betont, dass der Naturschutz durch dieses Gesetz nicht gewährleistet werde.

Bias read (Progressive): Der Artikel thematisiert die Kritik an politischen Entscheidungen, insbesondere an dem bayerischen Gesetz, das die Umweltverträglichkeitsprüfung für bestimmte Seilbahnprojekte entzieht. Die Darstellung betont die Gefahr für den Naturraum und fordert einen Schutz der Wildnis, was typisch für linke Um

Why factuality (85): The article provides detailed information about Herr Huber's involvement with Mountain Wilderness, including his transition from extreme mountaineering to environmental advocacy. It references specific projects like the Scheidtobelbahn and mentions ecological concerns related to the area's wildlife.

Why objectivity (75): The article presents Huber's perspective on environmental issues but frames them through his personal experience as an extreme climber. There is some emotional language regarding the importance of preserving natural areas, though it remains focused on factual descriptions of the project and its ecol

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories