Under-25s with ADHD and anxiety could get discount gym memberships
The UK government is considering prescribing non-medical interventions, such as discounted gym memberships and gardening clubs, for under-25s suffering from mental health issues like ADHD and anxiety. This approach stems from a major government review led by Professor Peter Fonagy of UCL, which argues that young people often seek practical support rather than formal diagnoses. The review highlights a significant rise in mental health conditions among those aged 16 to 24, noting that rates have increased by more than a third since 2014. It also points to a substantial increase in antidepressant prescriptions in England, reaching 85.6 million in 2022-23, alongside record levels of ADHD stimulant usage. The findings are influencing Labour Party policies on youth employment and welfare, particularly regarding the nearly one million young people currently not in education, employment, or training.
Australian scientists have proposed the existence of a distinct form of depression, termed "circadian depression," which accounts for approximately one-quarter of cases resistant to standard pharmaceutical interventions. The research team suggests that this specific subtype is driven by disruptions in the internal biological clock, making conventional antidepressants ineffective for many sufferers. Instead, the authors argue that therapies targeting sleep regulation, such as melatonin administration and light exposure, offer a safer and potentially more effective alternative. The findings were detailed in a paper published in the British Journal of Psychiatry, drawing on extensive genetic and clinical data from Australia. The study analyzed records from more than 11,000 participants enrolled in the Australian Genetics of Depression Study. Within this cohort, researchers identified 2,604 individuals, representing nearly 25 percent of the sample, who exhibited characteristics consistent with the newly defined circadian subtype. These patients displayed a pattern of illness influenced by seasonal changes, often experiencing excessive sleep during depressive episodes. Persistent fatigue was another hallmark, along with a preference for nocturnal activity, described colloquially as being a "night owl." Beyond immediate symptoms, the analysis indicated that these individuals tended to develop depression at a younger age compared to other patients. Their conditions were frequently more severe, with higher incidences of manic episodes and suicidal ideation. Genetic profiling further revealed an elevated risk for comorbidities, including heart disease, inflammatory conditions, and neurodevelopmental disorders such as attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Dr. Emiliana Tonini, a mental health researcher at the University of Sydney and the study’s lead author, emphasized that depression is not a monolithic condition. She stated that recognizing specific subtypes allows clinicians to provide earlier access to treatments tailored to the patient’s physiology. Co-author Dr. Jacob Crouse noted that because the condition is linked to circadian rhythms, interventions focused on resetting the body clock should be prioritized. He advised patients who find traditional medications ineffective to consult their clinicians regarding these alternatives. Professor Ian Hickie, a clinical psychiatrist at Sydney University’s Brain and Mind Centre, highlighted the urgency of identifying this subtype among young people. He observed that while selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors are typically the first line of defense, at least a quarter of young patients might benefit more from circadian-focused medical and behavioral strategies, including cognitive behavioral therapy designed to disrupt negative thought patterns. The timing of this publication coincides with rising concerns over antidepressant usage in England. Recent data indicates that one in seven adults in the country was prescribed these drugs last year, marking record-high consumption levels. Health authorities recently issued a safety alert warning that antidepressants can cause long-lasting sexual side effects and suicidal thoughts even after treatment cessation. In parallel, a separate government review led by Professor Peter Fonagy of University College London examined the surge in mental health diagnoses among under-25s. Rates of anxiety and depression in the 16-to-24 age group rose by more than a third over the past decade, climbing from 18.9 percent in 2014 to 25.8 percent in 2024. Prescriptions for antidepressants in England increased from 47.3 million in 2011 to 85.6 million in the 2022-23 period. Additionally, adult prescriptions for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder medications jumped 40 percent, reaching 267,000 in the 2025-26 fiscal year. Despite the novel classification proposed by the Australian team, some experts outside the study expressed skepticism. Professor David Curtis, a genetics specialist at University College London, argued that selecting patients based on specific symptom clusters does not necessarily prove the existence of a new biological subtype. He contended that the term "circadian" is misleading because typical depressive features, such as early morning waking and low mood upon waking, are inherently circadian in nature. Other commentators noted that the evidence is currently insufficient to justify changing clinical protocols broadly. However, the broader discourse on mental health care is shifting toward non-pharmacological solutions. Professor Fonagy and his colleague, Professor Sir Simon Wessely, advocated for "social prescribing," which involves referring patients to community activities like gardening clubs, sports programs, and arts groups. They argued that for many young people, social isolation and lack of engagement are primary drivers of distress, and that exercise and community involvement may be more effective than medication alone. This approach aligns with existing National Health Service schemes that offer discounted gym memberships through general practitioner referrals. The debate continues over whether these lifestyle interventions can adequately address the growing burden of mental health conditions, particularly as costs associated with unemployment and disability benefits for young people reach billions of pounds annually.
The UK government is considering prescribing non-medical interventions, such as discounted gym memberships and gardening clubs, for under-25s suffering from mental health issues like ADHD and anxiety. This approach stems from a major government review led by Professor Peter Fonagy of UCL, which argues that young people often seek practical support rather than formal diagnoses. The review highlights a significant rise in mental health conditions among those aged 16 to 24, noting that rates have increased by more than a third since 2014. It also points to a substantial increase in antidepressant prescriptions in England, reaching 85.6 million in 2022-23, alongside record levels of ADHD stimulant usage. The findings are influencing Labour Party policies on youth employment and welfare, particularly regarding the nearly one million young people currently not in education, employment, or training.
Bias read (Center): The article reports on specific government policy proposals and a commissioned review within the context of the ruling Labour Party's agenda. While the subject matter involves public health and welfare policy, the tone remains largely informational, citing expert opinions and statistical data from a
Why factuality (85): The article accurately reflects the core narrative of Professor Peter Fonagy's review regarding non-pharmacological interventions for youth mental health. It cites specific statistics (rise in anxiety/depression rates, antidepressant prescription numbers) that align with known data from UK health re
Why objectivity (90): The tone is largely neutral and informative. While it presents a specific perspective (that exercise/social activity should replace or supplement medication), it does so through direct quotes and attributed statements rather than editorializing. The framing is balanced enough to present the proposal
Ruth Grierson, mother of 17-year-old Henry Grierson, shared her tragic experience of discovering her son's suicide after using the Find My Phone app. Henry, a rugby player with ADHD, was permanently excluded from his college in April 2024, which contributed to his mental health struggles. After stopping his prescribed medication due to side effects, he turned to self-medication with cannabis. His parents learned of the exclusion via email and were unable to reach him before he died. An inquest later found that the college lacked updated information about Henry’s health and criticized the manner in which they communicated the exclusion. Ruth now advocates for better support for young people with ADHD.
Bias read (Center): The article focuses on a personal tragedy involving mental health, education policies, and institutional responses. While it touches on systemic issues such as school policies and mental health support, the framing remains balanced, presenting the mother's account alongside findings from the inquest
Why factuality (85): The article provides specific details such as Henry Grierson’s age, the timeline of events, his ADHD diagnosis, and the college’s role. These align with the cross-source consensus. However, some details like the exact nature of the altercation leading to exclusion are not elaborated upon, leaving mi
Why objectivity (75): The article uses emotionally charged language such as 'devastated mum' and 'couldn’t see a way out,' which may influence reader perception. While it presents both the family's perspective and the coroner's findings, it leans slightly toward the family's narrative without fully balancing potential in
Scientists have identified a new subtype of depression called 'circadian depression,' which affects up to a quarter of patients and is linked to disruptions in the body's internal clock. This form of depression is associated with issues like irregular sleep patterns, seasonal variations in symptoms, and a higher likelihood of developing the condition at a younger age. Traditional antidepressants appear less effective for this group, suggesting alternative treatments like melatonin or light therapy might be more beneficial. The research, published in the British Journal of Psychiatry, analyzed over 11,000 participants and highlighted potential genetic risks related to heart disease and other conditions. Researchers emphasize the importance of early diagnosis and personalized treatment approaches for individuals with this specific depression subtype.
Bias read (Center): The article discusses a scientific discovery related to a new subtype of depression and its implications for treatment. It presents findings from academic research without apparent ideological framing, focusing on medical insights rather than political debate. No political figures, policies, or idee
Why factuality (85): The article presents specific details about the study including the name of the condition ('circadian depression'), the percentage of affected individuals (~25%), the journal where the research was published (British Journal of Psychiatry), and the sample size (over 11,000 participants). These facts
Why objectivity (70): The article uses somewhat emotive language such as 'less risky fix' and mentions the 'new safety alert' regarding antidepressants, which might imply a bias towards alternative treatments. While it does quote a researcher, the overall tone suggests a preference for non-pharmacological solutions over
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.