Dok se klima-uređaji postaju sve popularniji u Europi, Europska komisija još uvijek izbjegava donošenje jasnog stavova o tome da li bi trebalo podržavati ili zabraniti njihovo korištenje. Ovo je posebno važno u kontekstu sve jače izraženog toplinskog vala koji je odnio barem 1.300 života, što je podstaknulo rasprave o potrebama građana za rashladnim sustavima. Prema podacima, klima-uređaji su ugrađeni u oko 20 posto europskih kućanstava, dok u Sjedinjenim Američkim Državama, Japanu i Južnoj Koreji njihov udio iznosi više od 90 posto. Iako je toplinski val postao politički osjetljivo pitanje, Europska komisija ostaje neutralna, tvrdi da nije njezina uloga određivati građanima što smiju ili ne smiju koristiti klima-uređaje, već se bavi tim pitanjem kroz politiku obnove zgrada, energetsku učinkovitost i stambenu strategiju.
Glavnica Europske komisije za klimatska pitanja, Anna-Kaisa Itkonen, objasnila je da Komisija nema stav „za ili protiv“ klima-uređaja, već se fokusira na pravilan prijelaz prema klimatskoj neutralnosti. Na pitanje je li Komisija trebala zauzeti jasniji stav s obzirom na rastući politički značaj ove teme, ona je odgovorila da je prioritet osigurati učinkovitu tranziciju prema klimatskoj neutralnosti. Ipak, nije isključila mogućnost da se pristup promijeni ako se političke okolnosti promijene. „Moramo razmotriti i pitanje koliko Komisija uopće treba građanima govoriti što smiju ili ne smiju raditi“, rekla je. „Prošlotjedni toplinski val vjerojatno je bio tek uvod u ostatak ljeta, pa nije isključeno da će ovo postati tema političkih rasprava. Ako države članice pokažu interes, Komisija će poduzeti odgovarajuće korake.“ Naglasila je da Komisija neće „mikroupravljati“ odlukama građana o tome hoće li u svojim domovima koristiti klima-uređaje.
Korištenje klima-uređaja već je godinama predmet rasprava u Europi. Protivnici upozoravaju da klimatizacija povećava potrošnju električne energije, dodatno opterećuje elektroenergetske mreže, ispušta toplinu u okoliš te ne rješava temeljne uzroke klimatskih promjena. S druge strane, zagovornici smatraju da su klima-uređaji postali nužni kako bi se osigurali podnošljivi životni uvjeti i očuvala produktivnost tijekom sve češćih i intenzivnijih toplinskih valova. U Francuskoj je krajnje desna stranka Nacionalno okupljanje (RN), koja prema anketama vodi uoči predsjedničkih izbora iduće godine, predložila subvencioniranu masovnu ugradnju klima-uređaja. Čak je i čelnica Zelenih Marine Tondelier priznala da klimatizacija „postaje nužnost“. Fokus je stavljen na čistu energiju, a ne na same uređaje. Europska komisija naglašava da se rasprava ne bi trebala voditi oko samih klima-uređaja, već oko izvora energije koji ih pokreće. Tijekom 2025. godine oko 47 posto ukupne električne energije u Europskoj uniji proizvedeno je iz obnovljivih izvora energije. Komisija idućeg mjeseca planira predstaviti Akcijski plan za elektrifikaciju, koji će sadržavati nove mjere za elektrifikaciju sustava grijanja i hlađenja u državama članicama. „Odluke o tome treba li nešto provesti ili ne provesti prvenstveno su u nadležnosti država članica“, istaknula je Itkonen.
Rasprava o klimatizaciji odvija se u trenutku kada Europska unija preispituje provedbu Zelenog plana (Green Deal), opsežnog paketa zakona čiji je cilj postići klimatsku neutralnost do 2050. godine. Iako cilj ostaje nepromijenjen, mnoge mjere koje podupiru tu tranziciju posljednjih su mjeseci pojednostavljene pod pritiskom država članica i industrije. Europska komisija u svojim službenim komunikacijama sve rjeđe koristi izraz „Green Deal“, a umjesto njega naglasak stavlja na pojmove „neto nulte emisije“ (net zero) i „dekarbonizacija“. U Parizu, zamjenica gradonačelnice Audrey Pulvar izazvala je burne reakcije nakon što je dio odgovornosti za razorni toplinski val u Francuskoj pripisala SAD-u. Ona je odgovorila na kritike američkih novinara i influencera koji su posljednjih dana prozivali Pariz zbog nedostatka klimatizacije u brojnim stanovima i javnim zgradama. „Dragi američki novinari i influenceri, danima me neki od vas kritiziraju i ismijavaju Pariz jer nema klimu u svakoj sobi. Koja ironija!“, napisala je Pulvar. „Kao jedan od najvećih svjetskih emitera stakleničkih plinova, snosite znatan dio odgovornosti za globalno zatopljenje i posljedice koje mi u Francuskoj sada proživljavamo.“
Dok se Francuska suočava s ekstremnim temperaturama, brojni stanovnici Pariza spas od nesnosne vrućine pronalaze izvan svojih domova. Budući da mnogi stanovi nemaju klime, građani noći provode spavajući u parkovima ili unajmljuju klimatizirane hotelske sobe, ponekad svega nekoliko metara od vlastitih stanova. Park Buttes-Chaumont na sjeveroistoku Pariza posljednjih je dana postao jedno od mjesta na kojem brojni stanovnici pokušavaju pronaći predah od visokih temperatura. Francuska tradicionalno ima rezerviran odnos prema klimatizaciji. Mnogi Francuzi vjeruju da nagli prijelaz iz velikih vrućina u rashlađeni prostor može izazvati zdravstvene tegobe poput prehlade, grlobolje ili takozvanog „toplinskog šoka“. Osim kulturnih razloga, ugradnja klima-uređaja u povijesne zgrade često je tehnički zahtjevna, a tema je godinama bila i politički osjetljiva. Danas klima-uređaj posjeduje tek oko četvrtine francuskih kućanstava, dok je taj udio znatno veći u Španjolskoj i Italiji, gd
6 reports
N1 HrvatskaIndependentCenterFactual 95Objective 803 days agoThe article discusses the growing political debate around air conditioning (AC) usage across Europe amid a severe heatwave, which has claimed at least 1,300 lives. While AC units are present in about 20% of European households, their adoption remains low compared to countries like the U.S., Japan, and South Korea. The European Commission has avoided taking a clear stance on whether citizens should use AC, emphasizing its role in energy efficiency and building renovation policies rather than dictating personal choices. Commission spokesperson Anna-Kaisa Itkonen stated that while the issue is becoming more politically significant, the focus remains on transitioning toward climate neutrality rather than micromanaging individual decisions. The debate highlights contrasting views: critics argue AC increases energy demand and contributes to environmental issues, while supporters see it as necessary for livability during extreme heat. Some political parties, including France’s far-right National Rally (RN) and Greens leader Marine Tondelier, have acknowledged the need for widespread AC installation. The Commission stresses that discussions should center on clean energy sources rather than
Bias read (Center): The article presents a balanced view of the debate surrounding air conditioning, highlighting both arguments for and against its use. It reports on the European Commission's cautious approach, avoiding a direct 'pro' or 'con' stance, and emphasizes policy frameworks over personal choice. The tone is
Why these scores (Factual 95 · Objective 80): The article provides factual information about the European Commission's stance on air conditioning and includes quotes from officials. It remains largely objective, though it does highlight the severity of the situation without delving into political debates.
tportalIndependentCenterFactual 92Objective 785 days agoAccording to climatologist Dragan Orlić, heatwaves in this part of Europe are becoming increasingly frequent, prolonged, and intense due to climate change. He explains that while specific daily temperatures cannot be predicted, long-term climate projections clearly indicate rising trends. The current heatwave is attributed to a meteorological pattern known as the 'omega' phenomenon, which traps hot air over a region for extended periods. This has led to record-breaking temperatures in Germany, the Czech Republic, and Poland, with Croatia experiencing slightly less severe conditions. Orlić highlights the impact of global warming, particularly the faster heating of the Arctic compared to equatorial regions, which alters atmospheric behavior and contributes to extreme weather events. He warns of the need for adaptation measures, such as adjusting work schedules and improving building energy efficiency, and notes the growing challenge of tropical nights where temperatures remain above 20°C even at night. Additionally, high sea temperatures are affecting marine ecosystems.
Bias read (Center): The article presents scientific findings and expert opinions on climate change and its effects, without overtly favoring any political stance. It focuses on factual information and does not include biased language or one-sided sourcing.
Why these scores (Factual 92 · Objective 78): The article presents scientific explanations about heatwaves and climate change objectively. It avoids taking sides and focuses on explaining the phenomenon through meteorological patterns and long-term climate projections.
Jutarnji listIndependentLeftFactual 90Objective 705 days agoThe article reports on extreme heatwaves across parts of Europe during early July, with temperatures reaching 40°C in some regions and other areas experiencing storms. In France, over 1,000 additional deaths linked to heat were recorded, primarily among elderly individuals. Scientists attribute these extreme conditions to climate change, noting that this heatwave is the worst recorded in Europe and has severely impacted healthcare systems, transportation, and energy production. The World Health Organization’s director warned that such events are becoming more frequent due to global warming and highlighted inadequate preparedness in European infrastructure. The article also mentions disruptions to power grids, railway services, and water levels in rivers affecting agriculture and energy generation.
Bias read (Left): The article frames the extreme heatwave as a direct consequence of human-caused climate change, emphasizing scientific consensus and warning of increased frequency due to global warming. It highlights the vulnerability of populations and infrastructure, aligning with progressive environmental and 's
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 70): The article accurately reports on the impact of the heatwave across Europe and cites WHO and health statistics. However, it uses emotive language ('dozens have died', 'infrastructure is failing') and places strong emphasis on human-caused climate change without balancing alternative viewpoints.
Index.hrIndependentLeftFactual 90Objective 655 days agoParis has partially blamed the United States for the deadly heatwave affecting France, according to an article by The Telegraph. Audrey Pulvar, deputy mayor responsible for international relations, criticized Americans who criticize France's limited use of air conditioning, stating that the US bears significant responsibility for global warming and its effects. She urged Americans to stop making 'performative' comments and start taking their share of responsibility. During the recent heatwave, Parisians trapped in hot apartments without air conditioning have resorted to sleeping outdoors in public parks. Green spaces like the Buttes-Chaumont Park have become makeshift open-air dormitories. France has long had a reserved attitude toward air conditioning, often associating it with illness due to the belief in 'thermal shock.' While the country is increasingly turning to air conditioning, installation in historic buildings is difficult and politically contentious. Only a quarter of French households have air conditioners, compared to 50% in Spain and Italy, and 90% in the US and Japan. Right-wing politician Marine Le Pen has called for mass subsidies for installing air conditioners, a
Bias read (Left): The article frames the issue through the lens of climate responsibility, emphasizing the role of the US in contributing to global warming and holding them accountable for the effects experienced in France. It highlights the political stance of France on air conditioning and includes commentary from左
Why these scores (Factual 90 · Objective 65): The article accurately reports Audrey Pulvar's comments linking US emissions to the heatwave. However, it uses emotionally charged language such as 'prodikama' and frames the issue in a way that emphasizes blame rather than presenting both sides neutrally.
Net.hrIndependentLeftFactual 88Objective 685 days agoA representative of Paris' mayor, Audrey Pulvar, sparked controversy by blaming the United States for part of the deadly heatwave affecting France. She responded to criticism from American journalists and influencers who had mocked Paris for lacking air conditioning in many homes and public buildings. Pulvar argued that the US, as one of the world's largest emitters of greenhouse gases, shares significant responsibility for climate change and its effects. Meanwhile, Parisians are seeking relief from extreme temperatures by sleeping in parks or renting air-conditioned hotel rooms. Cultural attitudes and technical challenges have historically limited the adoption of air conditioning in France, though opinions are shifting amid rising temperatures. Hospitals are under pressure, with preliminary data indicating a rise in deaths linked to the heatwave.
Bias read (Left): The article frames the situation through the lens of climate responsibility, emphasizing the role of major polluters like the US while highlighting the need for action. It presents the French perspective on climate change and critiques the US, aligning with a left-leaning viewpoint that emphasizes环保
Why these scores (Factual 88 · Objective 68): This article repeats similar content to article 1 but adds context about French attitudes towards air conditioning. While factual, it still has a biased tone by emphasizing American responsibility without providing counterpoints from other countries.
Jutarnji listIndependentCenterFactual 85Objective 752 days ago Na Mount Everestu pojavila se nova opasnost, bolnice šalju apele: ‘Nemamo protuotrov‘The article reports on a growing health crisis in Nepal related to venomous snake bites at high altitudes around Mount Everest. Hospitals near the mountain are struggling to secure antivenom as the range of venomous snakes expands due to climate change. Medical professionals note that rising temperatures and human activity are contributing to this trend, with cases now occurring in areas previously unaffected. Dr. Pawan Moktan from the Sotang hospital reported that approximately 30 patients have sought treatment for snake bites since April, with two requiring specialized care in Kathmandu. Professor Sanjib Kumar Sharma, an expert in snake bites, explained that snakes are moving into higher elevations, increasing risks for tourists and climbers. He emphasized that many deaths go unreported because victims often reach medical facilities too late. With Nepal warming faster than the global average, venomous snakes are surviving at higher altitudes, posing new dangers to local populations and visitors.
Bias read (Center): While the article discusses a significant environmental and public health issue, it presents information based on scientific observations and expert commentary without overtly promoting a specific ideological stance. It does not take a clear partisan position on policy solutions or political action,
Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 75): The article provides specific details about hospitals near Mount Everest dealing with snake bites, citing doctors and officials. However, some statements like 'global warming likely makes the environment more suitable for them' are generalized without precise data. The tone leans slightly toward ala
★
Keep the news honest.
ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.
Become a Supporter
Croatia
