ON
← Back to feed
She saved diligently for nine years, but the reason she was left speechless was shocking
Slovenia💼 Business

She saved diligently for nine years, but the reason she was left speechless was shocking

Nichole Niciforo, a resident of Queens, New York, lived frugally for nearly a decade to reduce her electricity bills, believing high costs were due to her own consumption. In 2016, she requested a meter review from utility provider Con Edison after noticing that savings did not lower her bills. It was later discovered that her electric meter had been incorrectly linked to the apartment above hers, meaning she was paying for her neighbor's usage. Con Edison acknowledged the error and refunded $6,000, but this covered only the previous six years due to statutory limitations, leaving approximately four years of overpayments unrecovered. Official records of her initial complaint could not be located. The article highlights this case as a warning for consumers to verify billing accuracy, noting similar incidents where customers paid tens of thousands of dollars for incorrect readings.

New York resident Nicole Niceforo discovered that her electricity meter had been connected to a neighboring apartment for nearly ten years, meaning she paid for another household’s energy consumption while restricting her own usage. The error was identified after a building manager inspected the meter following her persistent complaints. Con Edison, the utility provider, acknowledged the mistake and refunded $6,000, though this amount covered only six years of overcharges due to internal company rules. Niceforo first noticed unusually high bills from Con Edison for her apartment in Queens approximately a decade ago. Believing the costs reflected her personal consumption, she began conserving energy aggressively. She avoided using air conditioning even during extreme summer heat and unplugged electronic devices whenever she left home. In September 2016, she requested a meter inspection because the savings did not lower the bill totals. At that time, the building manager tested the device by asking her to turn on a microwave. Since the meter registered activity, officials deemed it functional, and she continued paying the inflated amounts. For nine more years, Niceforo endured unnecessary restrictions. She sent multiple emails to Con Edison regarding the discrepancies. The utility responded by attributing the high charges to summer temperatures and other external factors. It was not until a second inspection, conducted almost a decade later, that the truth emerged. The building manager found that Niceforo’s meter was physically linked to the unit above hers. Consequently, her bills reflected the neighbor’s electrical usage, not her own. The revelation shocked the resident. “I am angry,” she stated. She described spending enormous time and energy making phone calls to resolve the issue. “The disappointment was indescribable.” Upon reporting the error to Con Edison, the company admitted the fault and issued corrected invoices. The difference in billing was substantial. For one month, she was charged nearly $180, whereas her actual consumption cost only $41. Despite the admission of error, the financial restitution was limited. Con Edison returned $6,000, which represented less than the total amount Niceforo had overpaid. The utility explained that its internal policies allowed for corrections only within a six-year window. This meant that overpayments from the earlier period were excluded from the refund. A regulatory body upheld the distributor’s position, confirming that adjustments could only apply to that specific timeframe. Additionally, official records of her initial complaint from 2016 could not be located, despite her having flagged irregularities at that time. In a statement, Con Edison said it values customers and works with them when they believe bills do not reflect true usage. The company noted that building owners are generally responsible for equipment associated with meters. The case highlights broader issues in utility billing accuracy. Media reports indicate similar incidents have occurred elsewhere. One homeowner reportedly overpaid approximately $11,000 over seven years due to swapped meters. In another instance, a New York resident received a erroneous bill for $38 million, which was later corrected to $74. Niceforo’s experience resulted in years of lost comfort and unnecessary frugality. While she recovered part of the money, the decade of restricted living remained. Her story serves as a cautionary example for consumers to verify whether their bills align with their actual habits and household size. When usage does not match lifestyle patterns, checking for systemic errors in the billing system may be necessary. The resolution underscores the importance of accurate meter connections and the limitations of utility refund policies.

How this report was made. Objective News wrote this report from 2 source articles, using AI-assisted synthesis under our methodology. It is our own text, not a copy of any single outlet. Read our methodology.

Responsible editor: Matej BašaSpotted an error? Report it

2 reports

N1 Slovenija logoN1 SlovenijaIndependentCenterFactual 85Objective 90
For 10 years, she had been receiving high electricity bills. Then, she discovered who she had been paying them to.

A woman named Nicole Niceforo discovered after ten years of high electricity bills that her meter was incorrectly connected to a neighboring apartment, meaning she had been paying for another resident's usage. She initially suspected issues in 2016 but was told by Con Edison that high costs were due to external factors like summer heat. After persisting for nine more years, a building manager confirmed the meter error during a re-inspection. Con Edison acknowledged the mistake and issued corrected bills, revealing significant overcharges such as being billed $180 for a month where actual usage cost only $41. However, the utility company refunded only $6,000 based on internal rules limiting reimbursement to the previous six years, leaving the earlier overpayments uncompensated.

Bias read (Center): The article presents a straightforward consumer complaint regarding a billing error, using neutral language and including the company's official statement without editorializing or taking a political stance.

Why factuality (85): The article accurately reflects the core narrative found in the consensus of similar reports: a woman in New York paid inflated bills for nearly a decade due to a meter error linking her unit to another. It cites Fox 5 as a source. However, it omits specific financial details like the exact refund a

Why objectivity (90): The tone is largely neutral and journalistic. It uses standard reporting verbs ('reported', 'said') and presents the subject's quotes directly. There is no significant editorializing or emotional manipulation beyond quoting the subject's frustration.

Cekin logoCekinIndependentCenterFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 85
She saved diligently for nine years, but the reason she was left speechless was shocking

Nichole Niciforo, a resident of Queens, New York, lived frugally for nearly a decade to reduce her electricity bills, believing high costs were due to her own consumption. In 2016, she requested a meter review from utility provider Con Edison after noticing that savings did not lower her bills. It was later discovered that her electric meter had been incorrectly linked to the apartment above hers, meaning she was paying for her neighbor's usage. Con Edison acknowledged the error and refunded $6,000, but this covered only the previous six years due to statutory limitations, leaving approximately four years of overpayments unrecovered. Official records of her initial complaint could not be located. The article highlights this case as a warning for consumers to verify billing accuracy, noting similar incidents where customers paid tens of thousands of dollars for incorrect readings.

Bias read (Center): The article presents a consumer service failure as a factual narrative without attributing political intent or using partisan language, focusing solely on the operational error and financial impact.

Why factuality: no official source document/info detected

Why objectivity (85): The writing style is slightly more engaging/narrative ('left speechless', 'shock'), which borders on sensationalism but remains within acceptable bounds for feature journalism. It clearly distinguishes between the utility company's actions and the regulatory outcome, maintaining balance by explainin

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories