Court sets aside Sizekhaya’s National Lottery licence
The North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria invalidated the national lottery license awarded to Sizekhaya Holdings, ruling that Trade, Industry and Competition Minister Parks Tau violated procurement procedures by establishing an unauthorized ministerial committee to reassess bids. The court determined that this parallel evaluation process was not permitted under the original request for proposals, rendering the resulting license agreement between the minister, the National Lotteries Commission, and Sizekhaya legally void. Although the court noted that Tau acted in good faith and made no negative findings regarding the quality of Sizekhaya’s bid, it ordered the minister to disregard the committee’s recommendations and re-evaluate the tender within twelve months. To prevent operational disruptions, the court suspended the declaration of invalidity for two consecutive six-month periods, allowing time for a fresh decision and potential transition to a new operator if necessary. Unsuccessful bidders Ithuba Lottery and Ringeta Consortium, along with the Economic Freedom Fighters, welcomed the judgment, while Sizekhaya stated that lottery operations and prize payments would continue normally during the interim period.
The North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria invalidated the award of the Fourth National Lottery and Sports Pools licence to Sizekhaya Holdings on Monday. Judge Norman Davis ruled that Trade, Industry and Competition Minister Parks Tau illegally established a separate ministerial committee to reassess bids outside the prescribed tender process. The court declared the licence agreement between Tau, the National Lotteries Commission, and Sizekhaya invalid. It directed the minister to disregard the committee’s report and recommendations when reconsidering the award. The judge granted Tau twelve months to make a fresh decision on the licence. The ruling stems from review applications filed by unsuccessful bidders Ithuba Lottery and Ringeta Consortium. These groups challenged the legality and procedural fairness of the process that resulted in Sizekhaya receiving the eight-year licence in May 2025. In that month, Tau announced Sizekhaya as the successful bidder after evaluating eight applications. The court found that the appointment of the committee, which conducted a parallel evaluation of bids, was not provided for in the original request for proposals. Consequently, the minister’s reliance on this body rendered the initial award unlawful. To prevent immediate disruption to national lottery operations, the court suspended its declaration of invalidity for two consecutive six-month periods. The first six months allows Tau time to reconsider the licence award and make a new decision. If the minister decides not to re-award the licence to Sizekhaya, the subsequent six-month period permits negotiations with a new operator, the conclusion of a new licence agreement, and the implementation of transitional arrangements. During this interim phase, Sizekhaya stated that operations would continue as normal. Tickets remain on sale, draws proceed as scheduled, and prize payments continue. The company assured retailers, beneficiaries, and the public that funding for good causes through the National Lottery Distribution Fund would not be affected. Sizekhaya took over the National Lottery on 1 June 2026, replacing Ithuba Holdings, which had operated the lottery since 2015. Although the court made no adverse findings regarding the quality of Sizekhaya’s bid or its shareholders, and noted that Tau acted in good faith, the company expressed disappointment with the judgment. Ithuba and Ringeta welcomed the decision, citing previous concerns about the transparency of the selection process. The Economic Freedom Fighters, which intervened to challenge provisions of the Lotteries Act, also supported the ruling. They called for a transparent and lawful process free from political interference, stating that no politically connected individuals or entities should be favored based on proximity to those in power. The court ordered Sizekhaya, Tau, and the National Lotteries Commission to pay the legal costs incurred by Ithuba and Ringeta. The dispute highlights a contentious transition period for the lottery sector. Sizekhaya is partly owned by JSE-listed gambling group Goldrush Holdings. The company is led by KwaZulu-Natal businessmen Moses Tembe and Sandile Zungu, the latter of whom owns AmaZulu Football Club. Earlier in the legal proceedings, another unsuccessful bidder, Lekalinga, had approached the Gauteng High Court in June 2025 to seek similar relief. The current judgment effectively resets the administrative process, requiring the minister to act strictly within the bounds of the original tender documentation. The suspension order ensures that the public can still purchase tickets and claim prizes while the legal status of the operator remains under judicial scrutiny. The minister must now navigate the remaining timeframe to either validate a new award or facilitate a handover to a different entity.
The North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria has invalidated the decision by Minister Park Tau to award the Fourth National Lottery and Sports Pools Licence to Sizekhaya Holdings RF (Pty) Ltd. The court ordered the Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition to reconsider the award within 12 months, disregarding previous committee recommendations. To ensure continuity, the declaration of invalidity is suspended for two six-month periods, allowing time for potential renegotiation or transition if Sizekhaya does not retain the license. This ruling concludes a contentious bidding process involving eight applicants, where unsuccessful bidders like Lekalinga and Ithuba Lottery challenged the transparency of the selection. Sizekhaya, partially owned by Goldrush Holdings and led by Moses Tembe and Sandile Zungu, had been selected to replace Ithuba Holdings for an eight-year term starting in 2025.
Bias read (Center): The article relies exclusively on judicial findings and factual procedural details regarding the court order and bidding history, avoiding subjective adjectives or partisan commentary.
Why factuality (95): Accurately reflects the core legal outcome (setting aside the award, invalidating the contract, suspending invalidity for 6+6 months, and directing the minister to disregard the committee's report). It aligns perfectly with the cross-source consensus regarding the timeline and parties involved.
Why objectivity (98): Extremely neutral and factual reporting. Uses standard journalistic language ('controversial process', 'lucrative') without injecting opinion or bias.
The North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria invalidated the national lottery license awarded to Sizekhaya Holdings, ruling that Trade, Industry and Competition Minister Parks Tau violated procurement procedures by establishing an unauthorized ministerial committee to reassess bids. The court determined that this parallel evaluation process was not permitted under the original request for proposals, rendering the resulting license agreement between the minister, the National Lotteries Commission, and Sizekhaya legally void. Although the court noted that Tau acted in good faith and made no negative findings regarding the quality of Sizekhaya’s bid, it ordered the minister to disregard the committee’s recommendations and re-evaluate the tender within twelve months. To prevent operational disruptions, the court suspended the declaration of invalidity for two consecutive six-month periods, allowing time for a fresh decision and potential transition to a new operator if necessary. Unsuccessful bidders Ithuba Lottery and Ringeta Consortium, along with the Economic Freedom Fighters, welcomed the judgment, while Sizekhaya stated that lottery operations and prize payments would continue normally during the interim period.
Bias read (Center): The article relies exclusively on direct quotes from the court judgment and balanced reactions from both the winning bidder and the opposing parties, avoiding subjective adjectives or one-sided framing.
Why factuality (95): Correctly identifies the specific legal reasoning (illegal introduction of a ministerial committee outside the RFP process) and names the presiding judge. Accurately captures the suspension of invalidity and the directive to disregard the committee's report. Matches the consensus on the outcome.
Why objectivity (97): Maintains a professional, objective tone. Presents the court's findings and the parties' reactions neutrally without editorializing.
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.