ON
← Back to feed
Brescia, doctor, circumcises a newborn on the kitchen table and causes him serious injuries: sued because he had agreed to do it at home
Italy🏛️ PoliticsCenter8 hr. ago

Brescia, doctor, circumcises a newborn on the kitchen table and causes him serious injuries: sued because he had agreed to do it at home

Un cardiologo di 63 anni residente a Brescia è stato denunciato per aver eseguito una circoncisione su un neonato di pochi mesi nel tavolo della cucina della sua abitazione, causandogli gravi lesioni. I Nas di Brescia hanno aperto un'indagine dopo essere stati informati dai genitori, rilevando che l'intervento non era stato condotto in una struttura sanitaria autorizzata né rispettava i requisiti igienico-sanitari. La famiglia, di origine pakistana, aveva scelto questa pratica per motivi religiosi, ma il medico non era stato selezionato attraverso canali appropriati. Il professionista è accusato di lesioni colpose e riceverà una sanzione amministrativa di 30mila euro per aver violato le normative sulla salute pubblica.

A 63-year-old cardiologist has been denounced for performing a circumcision on a newborn baby in the kitchen table of the family’s home, resulting in severe injuries to the infant. The incident took place in Brescia, Italy, where authorities have launched an investigation into the unauthorized medical procedure. According to reports, the doctor conducted the operation without adhering to the necessary hygiene and safety standards required for such procedures, which were carried out in a private residence rather than an authorized healthcare facility. The newborn, who is just a few months old, belongs to a young Pakistani couple who opted for the circumcision due to religious reasons. They reportedly sought the assistance of the cardiologist after being referred by some relatives. However, instead of conducting the surgery in a licensed medical setting, the physician performed the operation on the kitchen table within the family's home. This action violated Italian regulations that mandate such procedures to take place exclusively in approved medical facilities equipped with proper sanitation and safety measures. The National Sanitary Surveillance Service (Nas) in Brescia initiated an investigation following the incident, leading to the formal denunciation of the cardiologist. The probe revealed that the doctor had not only performed the operation outside of a regulated environment but also caused significant harm to the child during the process. While the exact nature and cause of the injuries remain under examination, the doctor faces charges related to negligent injury as well as administrative penalties for carrying out the surgical intervention in an unauthorized location. The circumstances surrounding the incident highlight concerns about the potential risks associated with performing complex medical procedures in unsanctioned environments. Such practices can lead to serious complications due to the lack of appropriate equipment, sterile conditions, and emergency protocols typically found in professional healthcare settings. In this case, the decision to conduct the operation in a domestic space raises questions about both the legal implications and the health risks posed to the patient. Authorities continue to investigate whether the injuries sustained by the newborn directly resulted from the method used during the procedure. Meanwhile, the cardiologist is facing possible legal consequences, including fines up to 30,000 euros for violating the regulations regarding the execution of surgical interventions in unauthorized locations. The situation underscores the importance of ensuring that all medical procedures, especially those involving minors, are conducted in accordance with established health and safety standards to prevent similar incidents from occurring in the future.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and your personalized For You feed.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and your personalized For You feed.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and your personalized For You feed.

Become a Supporter

2 reports

Il Fatto Quotidiano logoIl Fatto QuotidianoIndependentCenterFactual 85Objective 7811 hr. ago
Clandestine circumcision on the kitchen table: newborn wounded, reported to a cardiologist in Brescia

Un neonato di origine pakistana è rimasto lesionato durante una circoncisione clandestina eseguita da un cardiologo privato in casa, senza l'uso di una struttura sanitaria autorizzata. L'intervento, organizzato da una giovane coppia in base alle loro tradizioni religiose, è avvenuto sul tavolo della cucina. I carabinieri del Nas di Brescia hanno indagato e hanno denunciato il medico, accusato di lesioni colpose e di aver violato le normative sanitarie. Gli accertamenti continuano per determinare se le ferite del bambino siano legate alle condizioni dell'intervento. Il medico, un cardiologo di 63 anni residente in Italia, potrebbe essere soggetto a una sanzione amministrativa di 30mila euro.

Bias read (Center): The article presents a factual account of a medical violation and legal consequences without overt ideological framing. It focuses on the legal and administrative aspects of unauthorized medical procedures rather than taking a partisan stance. The narrative remains neutral regarding the cultural or

Why these scores (Factual 85 · Objective 78): The article provides detailed information about the illegal circumcision performed by a doctor on a newborn at home, leading to injury and subsequent legal action. It aligns with the cross-source consensus regarding the location, nature of the violation, and outcome. The tone remains factual but inc

Open logoOpenIndependentCenterFactual 82Objective 758 hr. ago
Brescia, doctor, circumcises a newborn on the kitchen table and causes him serious injuries: sued because he had agreed to do it at home

Un cardiologo di 63 anni residente a Brescia è stato denunciato per aver eseguito una circoncisione su un neonato di pochi mesi nel tavolo della cucina della sua abitazione, causandogli gravi lesioni. I Nas di Brescia hanno aperto un'indagine dopo essere stati informati dai genitori, rilevando che l'intervento non era stato condotto in una struttura sanitaria autorizzata né rispettava i requisiti igienico-sanitari. La famiglia, di origine pakistana, aveva scelto questa pratica per motivi religiosi, ma il medico non era stato selezionato attraverso canali appropriati. Il professionista è accusato di lesioni colpose e riceverà una sanzione amministrativa di 30mila euro per aver violato le normative sulla salute pubblica.

Bias read (Center): L'articolo presenta fatti oggettivi riguardanti un caso specifico di violazione delle normative sanitarie senza evidenti inclinazioni ideologiche o polemiche. Non ci sono elementi che suggeriscano un bias a sinistra o destra, né un tentativo di favorire un lato politico. La descrizione rimane neutra

Why these scores (Factual 82 · Objective 75): This article corroborates the facts from the first source, including the doctor’s actions, the religious motivation, and the legal consequences. While it maintains consistency with the cross-source consensus, it uses slightly more emotionally charged phrasing, particularly around the severity of the

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €5/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories