ON
← Back to feed
Charity boss who screamed 'I am the CEO' at employee is ordered to pay her £2,000 in compensation
United Kingdom🏛️ PoliticsProgressiveOverlooked by conservatives

Charity boss who screamed 'I am the CEO' at employee is ordered to pay her £2,000 in compensation

An employment tribunal in Liverpool ordered Matthew Gibbs, the chief executive of the charity The Carrbridge Centre, to pay over £2,000 in compensation to former employee Julie Mayes for unfair dismissal. The tribunal accepted evidence that Gibbs exhibited aggressive behavior, including shouting, throwing objects, and using inappropriate sexualized language toward staff and volunteers. Mayes reported these incidents to charity trustees in July 2024, noting that the conduct triggered trauma responses among vulnerable employees. Following the report, Gibbs falsely accused Mayes of making allegations of sexual abuse, leading to her termination without a proper investigation. The ruling highlights failures in the charity’s management practices and due process during the dismissal.

A Liverpool employment tribunal has ordered a Merseyside charity to pay more than £2,000 in compensation to a former employee after her boss allegedly screamed "I am the CEO" at her during a confrontation. The ruling concludes an unfair dismissal case brought by Julie Mayes against The Carrbridge Centre. The tribunal found that the charity failed to conduct a proper investigation before firing Mayes, despite evidence suggesting her manager, Matthew Gibbs, engaged in aggressive behavior toward staff and volunteers. Mayes began her role as a Community Support Worker at The Carrbridge Centre on January 4, 2022. The charity provides support to vulnerable families, children, and the elderly in the Wirral area of Merseyside. Her duties included offering community support, distributing emergency food, and directing service users to other local services. During her tenure, Mayes reported experiencing increasing tension under the management of Gibbs. Over a period of six to eight months, she stated that his conduct deteriorated significantly. She attributed this change to what she perceived as mental health issues affecting Gibbs. According to testimony given to the tribunal, Gibbs frequently shouted, swore, and threw boxes in the workplace. One volunteer reportedly left their position as a direct result of this environment. Mayes also described Gibbs handling his dog roughly. Furthermore, she alleged that he used inappropriate sexualized language. On one specific occasion, she recalled seeing him jump onto a table while gyrating and thrusting his hips. Mayes told the tribunal that such behaviors eventually became the norm within the organization. In July 2024, Mayes raised these concerns directly with two of the charity’s trustees. She explained that many of the adults working with her or using the services had backgrounds involving abuse. Consequently, she argued that Gibbs’ behavior was inappropriate and could trigger traumatic feelings among them. However, the situation escalated shortly after this meeting. On August 21, 2024, a service user complained that crates were blocking the door to the charity’s hub. When informed, Gibbs reacted poorly, becoming angry and swearing at the volunteers present. Mayes attempted to intervene by standing between Gibbs and the volunteers. In response, Gibbs turned his anger toward her. He incorrectly accused her of having alleged that he had committed sexual abuse during the previous meeting with the trustees. Witnesses noted that he was screaming in her face, repeatedly declaring "I am the CEO." Mayes described feeling "in a state" following this incident. Although she was not formally suspended, she was instructed to work from home immediately afterward. The path to her dismissal began on September 4, 2024, when the trustees received an anonymous communication. The message came from an employee of a local housing association who claimed Mayes had been complaining about Gibbs at a community meeting. The sender accused her of riling others due to her concern over retaining her job. This information led the trustees to believe that a "witch hunt" against the CEO was underway. Following this accusation, a fact-finding meeting took place on September 12, 2024, between Mayes and the trustees. During this session, Mayes clarified that Gibbs had been responsible for several aggressive incidents directed at her, primarily characterized by him swearing at her. They reviewed the August 21 incident in detail, noting how Gibbs spoke inappropriately to service users and volunteers before turning aggressive toward Mayes. Mayes acknowledged that she might have used swear words in retaliation for standing up to his behavior. Despite the findings from the fact-finding process, the charity proceeded with disciplinary action. On September 30, 2024, Mayes was dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal determined that the dismissal was unfair because the trustees did not carry out a thorough or fair investigation into the allegations against her prior to terminating her contract. Instead, they relied heavily on the anonymous tip-off regarding the community meeting complaints. As part of the judgment, the tribunal awarded Mayes £2,160 in compensation. The decision highlights the failure of the charity’s internal procedures to protect employees from managerial aggression and to ensure due process in disciplinary matters. The case underscores the importance of impartial investigations when conflicts arise between senior leadership and staff members in charitable organizations. The ruling stands as a precedent for similar cases involving workplace harassment and procedural fairness in dismissals. The Carrbridge Centre serves a critical function in the Wirral community, addressing immediate needs through food provision and social support. The involvement of external parties, such as the housing association employee, complicated the internal dynamics of the dispute. The tribunal’s focus remained on whether the employer acted reasonably in dismissing the employee based on the available evidence at the time. By failing to adequately probe the claims of aggression and the context of the anonymous complaint, the charity breached its duty of care toward the employee. Gibbs’ actions, including the physical intimidation of jumping on tables and the verbal assault of shouting his title, formed the core of Mayes’ grievance. The progression from initial reports to final dismissal occurred over a span of three months. Each step revealed a breakdown in communication and conflict resolution within the charity. The final outcome ensures that Mayes receives financial recognition for the loss of her employment, which the tribunal deemed unjustified under the circumstances presented.

How this report was made. Objective News wrote this report from 2 source articles, using AI-assisted synthesis under our methodology. It is our own text, not a copy of any single outlet. Read our methodology.

Responsible editor: Matej BašaSpotted an error? Report it

2 reports

The Independent logoThe IndependentIndependentCenter
Charity ordered to pay employee compensation after boss screamed 'I am the CEO' at her

An employment tribunal in Liverpool ordered a local charity to pay over £2,000 in compensation to a former employee who was dismissed for gross misconduct. The tribunal accepted testimony that the charity’s CEO, Matthew Gibbs, exhibited aggressive behavior, including shouting, swearing, throwing objects, and using sexually suggestive language toward staff and volunteers. The employee, Julie Mayes, reported these incidents to the board of trustees but was subsequently fired after attempting to intervene during another instance of hostility. The ruling determined that the dismissal was unfair because the organization failed to conduct a proper investigation into the allegations before terminating her contract.

Bias read (Center): The report relies exclusively on tribunal findings and direct quotes regarding workplace conduct, presenting the legal outcome neutrally without ideological commentary or partisan framing.

Daily Mail logoDaily MailIndependentProgressive
Charity boss who screamed 'I am the CEO' at employee is ordered to pay her £2,000 in compensation

An employment tribunal in Liverpool ordered Matthew Gibbs, the chief executive of the charity The Carrbridge Centre, to pay over £2,000 in compensation to former employee Julie Mayes for unfair dismissal. The tribunal accepted evidence that Gibbs exhibited aggressive behavior, including shouting, throwing objects, and using inappropriate sexualized language toward staff and volunteers. Mayes reported these incidents to charity trustees in July 2024, noting that the conduct triggered trauma responses among vulnerable employees. Following the report, Gibbs falsely accused Mayes of making allegations of sexual abuse, leading to her termination without a proper investigation. The ruling highlights failures in the charity’s management practices and due process during the dismissal.

Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the story through the lens of corporate accountability and protection of vulnerable workers, emphasizing the employer's failure to provide a safe environment and the lack of due process in the dismissal.

How each side covered it

The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.

How each side covered it

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Covered around the world

The same event as reported in other countries.

Covered around the world

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Claims check

Key factual claims, and how many sources assert vs dispute each.

Claims check

Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.

Become a Supporter

Keep the news honest.

ObjectiveNews is reader-funded and ad-free — we show you the bias instead of hiding it. Support independent journalism for €4/month.

Become a Supporter

Related stories