'Case against Dada is completely false': Pregnant patient's family defends Shiv Sena corporator in hospital assault row

Hindustan TimesIndependentProgressive17 hr. ago

The family of a pregnant woman who was allegedly denied medical care at a hospital in Dombivli has publicly defended Shiv Sena corporator Mahesh Mhatre, claiming the case against him is 'completely false.' The patient's mother stated that hospital staff refused to treat her daughter despite her critical condition and advised them to seek care at another facility. The family reported that heavy flooding made travel difficult and that they urgently needed immediate assistance. After unsuccessful attempts to get help, they contacted Mhatre, who reportedly intervened. Mhatre has since expressed regret over the incident but denied any physical assault, stating that he only touched a doctor's hand to gain her attention during a conversation. He claims the CCTV footage may be misleading due to camera angles.

Bias read (Progressive): The article frames the situation by highlighting the family's defense of Mhatre, a member of the Shiv Sena party, which is generally associated with right-wing politics in India. However, the narrative leans left by emphasizing the family's perspective and questioning the validity of the charges, as

Hindustan TimesIndependentCenter20 hr. ago

Shiv Sena corporator Ramesh Mhatre responded to allegations of assaulting doctors and nurses at Shashtri Nagar Hospital, denying any physical aggression and attributing the incident to a misunderstanding over medical care. He claimed the CCTV footage may appear misleading due to camera angles and emphasized that his group does not condone violence against women. A police case was filed against Mhatre and five others under various legal provisions related to assault and public disorder. The incident reportedly occurred after doctors referred a pregnant patient to another hospital due to lack of NICU capacity, leading to a confrontation where both medical staff and interveners were allegedly attacked.

Bias read (Center): The article presents Mhatre's denial of physical aggression and includes direct quotes from him, while also citing police actions and victim accounts. It provides balanced information without overtly favoring either side, allowing readers to form their own conclusions based on multiple perspectives.

Times of IndiaIndependentCenter21 hr. ago

Shiv Sena corporator Ramesh Mhatre denied allegations of assaulting a female doctor during a physical altercation at a civic hospital. He attributed the incident to poor camera angles and claimed he only tapped the doctor's hand, referring to her as 'like a daughter to me.' Mhatre blamed systemic hospital shortcomings for the confrontation. Authorities have registered a case against Mhatre and five other individuals involved.

Bias read (Center): The article presents Mhatre's denial of assault and his explanation regarding camera angles, while also noting the formal registration of a case against him and others. There is no overt ideological framing or emphasis on specific political agendas beyond the individual's defense. The tone remains客观