'Cannot behave like an Indian': HC raps Imran Khan; asks govt to be 'magnanimous'
The Bombay High Court continued interim relief against a Leave India Notice issued to actor Imran Khan, a US citizen holding an Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) card. The Central government’s Foreigner Registration Regional Officer had ordered Khan to depart within two weeks following an FIR for unlawful assembly related to protests against voter roll revisions. The bench, led by Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi, emphasized that OCI holders are not Indian citizens and instructed Khan to provide an unconditional apology and an undertaking stating he had no association with the protest organizers. While the government argued that Khan instigated unrest on social media, his legal team contended that he was merely passing by and invoked Article 21 of the Constitution regarding the right to life and liberty for non-citizens. The court noted the distinction between the rights of citizens and OCI holders, particularly concerning the right to protest.
The Bombay High Court issued a stern rebuke to American actor Imran Khan on Monday, directing him to submit an unconditional apology for his presence at an anti-election reform protest in Mumbai. A division bench comprising Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi and Justice Advait Sethna stated that Khan, a United States citizen holding an Overseas Citizen of India card, does not possess the constitutional right to protest in India. The judges emphasized that the rights afforded to OCI cardholders differ fundamentally from those of Indian citizens. Following the hearing, the court kept the government’s order requiring Khan to leave the country in abeyance until the next scheduled hearing on December 7. The legal dispute stems from events on October 10, when Khan was present at a demonstration against the Special Intensive Revision of voter rolls and Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. The protest took place at August Kranti Maidan in Mumbai. Police detained Khan at the scene, an incident that prompted Bharatiya Janata Party leader Kirit Somaiya to file a police complaint. Somaiya alleged that Khan violated the terms of his OCI card and visa conditions by joining the agitation. The police forwarded this complaint to the Foreigners Regional Registration Office. In response to the complaint, the FRRO issued a Leave India notice to Khan on October 14. The directive ordered him to depart India by October 28. Khan challenged this order in the Bombay High Court, arguing that the notice was arbitrary and violated his fundamental rights. His legal team contended that while specific political rights might be restricted, the principles of natural justice and the right to life under Article 21 of the Constitution apply to non-citizens. During the Monday hearing, the bench questioned Khan’s motive for being at the protest site. The judges noted that Khan had no professional or personal connection to the issues raised in the demonstration. "What for were you there?" the court asked. The bench pointed out that the agitation concerned the election revision process, with which Khan had no involvement. The judges stated that an OCI cardholder is at the mercy of the host country and cannot reside in India while criticizing its policies. They warned that if an Indian citizen engaged in similar conduct abroad, they would face immediate deportation. Khan’s senior counsel, VR Dhond, argued that Khan had no association with the organizers of the protest, identified as the Cockroach Janta Party. Dhond stated that Khan was merely passing by and became curious about the gathering before police barriers were fully established. The lawyer further noted that Khan has resided in India for 42 years, having arrived at age two, and has built his career and family life there. Dhond asserted that Khan was ready to provide an undertaking that he had no part in the protest. Representing the central government, Additional Solicitor General Anil Singh countered these claims. Singh argued that the center possesses the discretionary power to expel foreigners without needing a foundational legal basis beyond their foreign status. He described Khan’s explanation of arriving out of curiosity as misleading, pointing to interviews Khan had given regarding the event. Singh maintained that a visa or OCI card does not grant a foreigner unlimited rights to enter or remain in India, particularly when engaging in political dissent. The court rejected the argument that an affidavit alone would suffice. Instead, the bench demanded an unconditional apology from Khan. Khan complied during the proceedings, offering the apology and providing an undertaking that he would not participate in similar protests in the future. The judges invoked the concept of vasudhaiva kutumbakam, meaning the world is one family, suggesting that the government could show magnanimity in allowing him to remain in the country if the apology was accepted. Background details indicate that Khan had initially tried to explain his presence through social media. On October 12, his partner Lekha Washington posted on Instagram claiming that the couple were walking toward the site to inquire about a detained friend when they were surrounded by media. She stated that Khan told reporters he had no demands and was not part of any organization. However, video footage shows Khan speaking at the protest, stating he was there as a resident of Mumbai to observe restrictions on freedom of movement. Police registered a First Information Report against Khan for unlawful assembly following his detention. While the charges include disobedience of orders and unlawful assembly, all listed offenses are bailable. Khan has not yet been summoned for interrogation despite the FIR. The court observed that Khan’s OCI registration lists him as unemployed, a detail the judges highlighted during their questioning regarding his activities in the country. The legal battle highlights the tension between the privileges granted to OCI cardholders and the limitations imposed on their civic engagement. The OCI scheme allows individuals of Indian origin to live and work in India indefinitely, but it does not confer citizenship. Consequently, participants in the legal proceedings agreed that the right to protest, typically protected under Article 19 for citizens, does not extend to OCI holders. The court’s decision to pause the expulsion order pending a final ruling on December 7 leaves Khan in a precarious legal position, dependent on the acceptance of his apology and the subsequent review of the FRRO’s actions.
Go to the primary sources (4)
The official sources this coverage is built on. Read them directly to bypass framing.
Actor Imran Khan, a US citizen holding an Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) card, appeared before the Bombay High Court regarding his detention at an anti-Special Intensive Revision (SIR) protest in Mumbai. The court reprimanded him, stating that OCI holders do not possess the same rights as Indian citizens and therefore cannot participate in domestic political protests. Following a complaint filed by BJP leader Kirit Somaiya, the Foreigners' Regional Registration Office had issued a 'Leave India' notice, which the court initially stayed. The bench ordered Khan to provide an unconditional apology and clarified that while he may protest in the United States, such actions are not tolerated within India under his current visa status. Khan maintained in court that he did not actively participate in the protest or cross police barricades, claiming he was merely inquiring about a detained friend.
Bias read (Conservative): The article emphasizes the court's restrictive stance on foreign nationals' political rights and highlights the role of a BJP leader in initiating legal action, reflecting a conservative framing of civic duties versus state security.
The Bombay High Court continued interim relief against a Leave India Notice issued to actor Imran Khan, a US citizen holding an Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) card. The Central government’s Foreigner Registration Regional Officer had ordered Khan to depart within two weeks following an FIR for unlawful assembly related to protests against voter roll revisions. The bench, led by Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi, emphasized that OCI holders are not Indian citizens and instructed Khan to provide an unconditional apology and an undertaking stating he had no association with the protest organizers. While the government argued that Khan instigated unrest on social media, his legal team contended that he was merely passing by and invoked Article 21 of the Constitution regarding the right to life and liberty for non-citizens. The court noted the distinction between the rights of citizens and OCI holders, particularly concerning the right to protest.
Bias read (Center): The report neutrally presents conflicting arguments from both the government and the petitioner, quoting specific judicial remarks and legal defenses without adopting a partisan stance.
The Bombay High Court ruled that Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) cardholders do not possess the legal right to protest in India, citing the example that Indian citizens protesting abroad would face repatriation. The court ordered actor Imran Khan, a US citizen holding an OCI card, to issue an unconditional apology for participating in a demonstration against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar in Mumbai in October. Khan complied with the order and provided an undertaking that he would not engage in similar protests while holding OCI status. This decision effectively suspended a previous 'Leave India' notice issued by the Foreigners Regional Registration Office, which had demanded Khan depart the country by late October due to his involvement in the protests. The court emphasized that OCI holders are not Indian citizens and therefore lack certain constitutional rights, including the freedom to demonstrate.
Bias read (Conservative): The headline frames the court's ruling as a definitive denial of rights rather than a procedural suspension, and the inclusion of a linked opinion piece criticizing the treatment of OCIs under the current government signals a critical stance toward state authority.
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.