Barnaby Joyce is already talking down One Nation’s chances in Victoria
Barnaby Joyce, a senior figure in One Nation, has publicly downplayed the party's electoral prospects in the upcoming Victorian state election, arguing that the result will be determined more by preference flows from a struggling Labor government than by One Nation's national standing. This cautious assessment contrasts sharply with the rhetoric of One Nation’s Victorian leader, Warren Pickering, who has asserted that the party aims to form a government on its own. Election analyst Antony Green noted that internal nervousness within the federal party is driving Joyce's strategy to manage expectations, predicting One Nation will secure only a handful of seats as conservative voters consolidate behind the Liberal Party. The article highlights specific controversies involving Pickering, including his inability to answer basic economic questions and his defense of a candidate linked to conspiracy theories regarding historical tragedies. These state-level contests are viewed as critical indicators for One Nation's viability ahead of the next federal election.
One Nation’s federal member for New England, Barnaby Joyce, has publicly downplayed his party’s electoral prospects in the upcoming Victorian state election, arguing that the true test of the party's momentum lies in New South Wales next year. Speaking to The Age and the Sydney Morning Herald, Joyce stated that critics seeking to diminish One Nation’s standing view Victoria as a "litmus test," but he contended that the New South Wales poll would provide a more accurate measure of the party's national trajectory. This assessment stands in sharp contrast to the rhetoric of One Nation’s Victorian leader, Warren Pickering, who has asserted that the party intends to form a government in its own right. The divergence in messaging highlights internal anxiety within One Nation regarding its performance in Victoria, where the party faces a challenging electoral landscape. Green, a prominent election analyst, noted that One Nation is effectively managing expectations to mitigate potential embarrassment should the party fail to secure a significant number of lower house seats. He predicted that One Nation would win a maximum of approximately six lower house seats in Victoria. According to Green, the party’s primary vote has drifted into the low twenties, a level insufficient to secure plurality in many electorates. Consequently, One Nation is likely to finish second in numerous rural and regional districts but fail to win because Labor preferences will flow to Coalition candidates, predominantly from the Nationals. In urban areas, Green suggested that while One Nation may finish second in traditional working-class seats, a reduced Liberal vote could prevent the party from accumulating enough preferences to surpass Labor. Despite these challenges in the lower house, analysts believe One Nation is poised to capture a substantial number of upper house seats, which do not rely on preference flows. This representation would grant the party significant leverage to influence any future Coalition government toward the political right. The strategic focus on New South Wales is underscored by the fact that both the Victorian election this month and the New South Wales election in March will serve as critical indicators for the party’s prospects in the federal election scheduled for mid-2028. In New South Wales, Labor Premier Chris Minns has recently identified One Nation, rather than the struggling state Coalition opposition, as his primary political rival. Similar to the outcome in South Australia, where Premier Peter Malinauskas retained power while One Nation gained ground, Minns is viewed as unlikely to lose his position, creating an environment where discontented voters may opt for a protest vote for One Nation. The tension between the federal leadership and the Victorian branch is further illustrated by recent controversies involving Pickering. A former soldier who has acknowledged past drug use, Pickering struggled to identify the cash rate during an interview with the conservative outlet News24. Additionally, on the Nine network’s Today program, Pickering defended a candidate who promoted the appearance of a member associated with conspiracy theories regarding the Port Arthur massacre and the September 11 attacks. When questioned about One Nation candidate Mark Nicholson’s claim that a One Nation government would imprison former premiers Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan by Christmas, a statement shared on the party’s social media platforms, Pickering maintained that Nicholson had been taken out of context. Meanwhile, the Nationals face their own existential questions heading into these state polls. Matt Canavan, who has announced plans to transfer from the Senate to the House of Representatives, is positioned as the favorite to win the central Queensland seat of Capricornia. However, the broader concern for the Nationals is whether their current parliamentary cohort will survive until Canavan takes his seat in 2028. For decades, observers have forecasted the decline of the Nationals, yet current trends suggest the situation is particularly severe for the New South Wales branch. One Nation is actively expanding its membership base and volunteer network in regions traditionally held by the Nationals. The May Farrer by-election served as a notable indicator of this shift, as the seat was previously held by the late Tim Fischer, a former Nationals leader and Deputy Prime Minister. In Victoria, the state Nationals anticipate retaining most of their nine lower house seats, with one considered at risk. They aim to capture the Bendigo East seat, currently held by former Premier Jacinta Allan, who is retiring. Internal polling suggests that the name recognition of existing Victorian Nationals members provides a roughly ten percent advantage. Conversely, the outlook in New South Wales appears grim, with discussions suggesting the possibility of a near-total loss of the party’s eleven lower house seats. The complex nature of the New South Wales optional preferential voting system adds another layer of difficulty to their campaign efforts. Historical data indicates that the Nationals typically hold a larger share of Coalition seats when the Coalition is in opposition compared to when it holds government. At the 2025 federal election, the Nationals secured nearly 36 percent of Coalition seats, marking their highest proportion since World War II. However, this retention of seats has masked significant declines in primary votes across many New South Wales electorates over the last two election cycles. These underlying weaknesses are expected to manifest in the upcoming state election. Between the 2025 federal election and the departure of David Littleproud as leader in March, the Nationals made several strategic errors, including splitting the Coalition twice, which led to perceptions of unpredictability. The party also suffered a major blow with the defection of Barnaby Joyce to One Nation. Although Joyce was a disruptive figure within the Nationals, his departure is viewed as damaging to the party’s cohesion. His presence in One Nation has added weight to the organization and acted as a moderating influence on federal leader Pauline Hanson. Joyce frequently engages in confrontations with Australian Broadcasting Corporation interviewers, a role that serves to balance the party’s stricter stance against the public broadcaster. His defection has also encouraged some regional Coalition voters to consider supporting One Nation. Canavan, while perhaps not matching the stature of past Nationals leaders such as Doug Anthony, Ian Sinclair, or Peter Nixon, is described as tough, diligent, and a strong communicator. With a first-class honors degree in economics and experience at the Productivity Commission, he possesses economic literacy that allows the Nationals to pursue independent policy paths, occasionally causing friction with the Liberal Party. The coming months will determine whether the Nationals can withstand the encroachment of One Nation and maintain their relevance in Australian politics.
3 reports
The AgeIndependentConservativeFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 90
Barnaby Joyce, a senior figure in One Nation, has publicly downplayed the party's electoral prospects in the upcoming Victorian state election, arguing that New South Wales will be a more accurate indicator of the party's national strength. He suggested that poor polling by the incumbent Labor government in Victoria would benefit the Liberal Party through preference flows, potentially limiting One Nation's seat count despite high primary votes. This cautious stance contrasts sharply with the rhetoric of One Nation's Victorian leader, Warren Pickering, who has asserted that the party aims to form a government independently. Election analyst Antony Green noted that internal nerves within the federal leadership are driving this strategy to manage expectations, predicting One Nation may secure only a handful of lower house seats. The article highlights specific controversies involving Pickering, including his inability to answer basic economic questions and his defense of a candidate linked to conspiracy theories regarding historical tragedies.
Bias read (Conservative): The article frames One Nation leaders' statements as evasive or contradictory, uses terms like 'nervousness' and 'disparage', and highlights embarrassing gaffes such as failing to cite the cash rate or defending conspiracy theorists, creating a skeptical tone toward the party's competence.
Why factuality: no official source document/info detected
Why objectivity (90): The tone is largely neutral and journalistic. While the headline uses the phrase 'talking down,' which carries a slight connotation of strategic manipulation, the body text presents both sides' perspectives fairly and relies on direct quotes rather than editorializing.
The Sydney Morning HeraldIndependentConservativeFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 90
Barnaby Joyce, a senior figure in One Nation, has publicly downplayed the party's electoral prospects in the upcoming Victorian state election, arguing that the result will be determined more by preference flows from a struggling Labor government than by One Nation's national standing. This cautious assessment contrasts sharply with the rhetoric of One Nation’s Victorian leader, Warren Pickering, who has asserted that the party aims to form a government on its own. Election analyst Antony Green noted that internal nervousness within the federal party is driving Joyce's strategy to manage expectations, predicting One Nation will secure only a handful of seats as conservative voters consolidate behind the Liberal Party. The article highlights specific controversies involving Pickering, including his inability to answer basic economic questions and his defense of a candidate linked to conspiracy theories regarding historical tragedies. These state-level contests are viewed as critical indicators for One Nation's viability ahead of the next federal election.
Bias read (Conservative): The article frames One Nation leaders through negative anecdotes like 'drug use' and 'conspiracy theories', while citing an external expert to predict failure rather than relying solely on party optimism.
Why factuality: no official source document/info detected
Why objectivity (90): Same assessment as Article 0. The presentation is balanced, allowing the reader to see the internal party disagreement clearly without imposing a judgment on which stance is correct.
The Conversation (AU)IndependentProgressiveFactual: no official source document/info detectedObjective 75
This article examines the declining electoral position of the Australian National Party, particularly in New South Wales, against the backdrop of rising support for One Nation. It notes that while the Nationals retained a significant share of Coalition seats in the 2025 federal election, their primary vote has dropped sharply in NSW, raising fears of a major loss of representation in upcoming state elections. The piece highlights internal party issues, including leadership changes under David Littleproud and the departure of prominent figure Barnaby Joyce to One Nation, as factors contributing to their vulnerability. While the Victorian branch appears more stable due to local identity and weaker competition from One Nation, the NSW branch faces potential wipeouts in lower house seats. The analysis suggests that current trends indicate a serious threat to the party's future viability if these patterns continue into the 2028 federal election.
Bias read (Progressive): The framing emphasizes the 'demise' and 'dire' prospects of the center-right Nationals, uses critical terms like 'wilful,' 'unpredictable,' and 'costly mistakes' regarding their coalition strategy, and frames the rise of One Nation as a direct consequence of internal National failures rather than independent voter shifts.
Why factuality: no official source document/info detected
Why objectivity (75): The title asks if the Nationals are on 'life support,' which is a loaded rhetorical device suggesting imminent death. The body text uses strong descriptors like 'marauding' and 'dire,' indicating a more opinionated or analytical stance rather than pure neutrality. It leans toward a narrative of decl
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.