Neofascist violence threatens in Milan, Piazza united also with blacks: student collectives challenge the apolitics of Telegram. Use secret chats and encrypted messages
In preparation for protests scheduled for October 24th in Milan and other northern Italian cities, members of the Telegram group 'Movimento 17 Ottobre' are distributing flyers and organizing demonstrations. The group has over 3,500 members and has generated more than 1,600 messages within 24 hours. Discussions within the group reveal divisions between those advocating for traditional protest methods, such as banners and security teams to manage potential infiltrators, and others who emphasize unity across political lines, including participation by Black individuals. Left-wing student collectives oppose the inclusion of far-right groups in the protests, while some Telegram users argue for collective action against fascism. Tensions also exist between these student groups and organizers of the Instagram page 'Italiainpiazza17,' who are seen as less politically defined. Concerns about possible violence from far-right elements and military presence at the demonstrations have been raised within the group.
Protests in Milan turned violent over the weekend, with clashes erupting in Piazza Duomo and surrounding areas. At least four adults were placed in custody following the unrest, while 11 minors were detained or placed under house arrest. A judge ruled that there was a "precise plan to destabilize public order," citing the high risk of similar incidents occurring again soon. The judge noted that the violence could escalate further, given the continued calls for protests on social media platforms such as Italy in Piazza and Movimento 17 Ottobre. The unrest began on Saturday, October 17, with reports of individuals using encrypted messaging apps to organize demonstrations. These groups included both political activists and those who described themselves as apolitical. Some users within these chats expressed concerns about potential infiltration by neo-fascist elements, while others advocated for unity among protesters regardless of their political affiliations. Discussions ranged from traditional methods of organization, such as forming processions with banners and security teams, to more radical ideas, including occupying government buildings and misleading police forces. The situation escalated rapidly, leading to widespread damage in central Milan. Businesses suffered extensive losses, and several stores were looted. Authorities responded by implementing preventive detention measures for the first time in the city, resulting in approximately 40 arrests. The violence prompted discussions among officials regarding the need for increased military presence in the area. However, Defense Minister Guido Crosetto questioned the effectiveness of simply increasing troop numbers without clear guidelines on how they would operate. President Sergio Mattarella addressed the issue during his speech at the National Assembly of Italian provinces. He emphasized the necessity of conducting an in-depth analysis into the origins of the violence, which he described as coming from "new subjects." Many of these individuals were teenagers, some as young as 12 years old. Mattarella called for careful monitoring to address the unexpected nature of the violence and its impact on public safety. Meanwhile, singer Ghali commented on the events during the Rome Film Festival. While condemning the acts of violence, he urged attention to the underlying reasons behind the peaceful demonstrations. He argued that the youth's search for answers should not be overshadowed by the focus on violent episodes. His remarks highlighted the broader societal issues that have led to the current unrest. The debate over the role of the military in maintaining public order continues. Deputy Prime Minister Matteo Salvini announced plans to deploy additional troops to protect Milan, but Crosetto cautioned against this approach unless specific operational guidelines were established. The discussion reflects ongoing tensions between different factions within the government regarding how best to handle the growing challenges posed by the protests.
In preparation for protests scheduled for October 24th in Milan and other northern Italian cities, members of the Telegram group 'Movimento 17 Ottobre' are distributing flyers and organizing demonstrations. The group has over 3,500 members and has generated more than 1,600 messages within 24 hours. Discussions within the group reveal divisions between those advocating for traditional protest methods, such as banners and security teams to manage potential infiltrators, and others who emphasize unity across political lines, including participation by Black individuals. Left-wing student collectives oppose the inclusion of far-right groups in the protests, while some Telegram users argue for collective action against fascism. Tensions also exist between these student groups and organizers of the Instagram page 'Italiainpiazza17,' who are seen as less politically defined. Concerns about possible violence from far-right elements and military presence at the demonstrations have been raised within the group.
Bias read (Center): The article presents both perspectives, left-wing student collectives opposing far-right involvement and Telegram users advocating for inclusive, unified protests, without overtly favoring one side. The framing remains neutral, focusing on reported discussions and concerns rather than taking a stance.
In Milan, four adults were placed in custody and a fifth was put under electronic monitoring after being arrested during violent protests in the city center. The judge overseeing the case stated there is a high risk of similar incidents recurring soon and that there is an organized plan to destabilize public order. The protests involved physical confrontations with police and attacks on shops. The judge noted that similar situations arose the day after the initial incident, with new calls for demonstrations spreading through social media accounts such as 'Italia in Piazza' and 'Movimento 17 Ottobre.' Investigations are ongoing into whether these events were premeditated and if there was organizational coordination behind them. The judge emphasized that the violence sparked by these protests has created a cycle where young people lose self-control and become participants in further acts of violence.
Bias read (Conservative): The article frames the protests as part of a deliberate plan to destabilize public order, using strong terms like 'preciso progetto di destabilizzazione' (precise plan for destabilization), 'rischio riaccada' (risk of recurrence), and describes the protesters as losing control and becoming 'violent'
At the Rome Film Festival, singer Ghali addressed the recent protests and disturbances in Milan. While condemning the violent incidents, he urged people not to let them overshadow the peaceful intentions behind the demonstrations. Ghali emphasized that young people have been seeking answers for a long time and that these concerns need to be heard. He noted that this issue affects not just the younger generation but the entire country.
Bias read (Center): The article presents Ghali’s comments neutrally, focusing on his call to balance attention between the violence and the underlying peaceful motivations of the protests. There is no overtly biased language or selective sourcing that would indicate a clear ideological lean.
How each side covered it
The same event, grouped by the political lean of the outlets covering it.
progressive
center
conservative
★
How each side covered it
Support independent, bias-aware news and unlock the social pulse, community voting, and every other Supporter feature.
Italy
