ItalyThe European Court of Human Rights has condemned Italy over its handling of a case involving Audrey Ubeda, a French citizen living in Italy who reported domestic violence against her by her former partner. The court criticized Italian authorities for inadequate protection of Ubeda and her two children, citing structural deficiencies in addressing gender-based violence. The ruling highlights concerns about sexist stereotypes reflected in legal proceedings, including dismissive remarks about 'normal' male sexual dominance and trivializing incidents as mere 'bad jokes.' These comments were deemed to have caused secondary victimization, where institutions inadvertently harm victims through biased interpretations. The court references previous warnings from the GREVIO, an EU body monitoring compliance with the Istanbul Convention, which had already raised alarms about persistent gender stereotypes in Italy’s judicial system.
Tendenz-Einschätzung (Links): The article frames the issue as a systemic failure within Italy's justice system to protect women from domestic violence, emphasizing the role of sexist stereotypes in legal reasoning. It criticizes the Italian judiciary for perpetuating harmful norms rather than upholding international human rights
